The decision is in your hands now, Star fans! Cast your vote online up to 10 times per day until 5pm on Tuesday.
Want a closer look at the pilots? Watch all four right here:
More posts from Sara Levine.
- WATCH: Comeback Kitchen Finalists’ Early Days of Stardom
- QUIZ: Which Food Network Show Would You Win?
- Exclusive: Giada on the “Ballet” of Camera Work, Plus Her Take on the Job of a Food Network Star
- Exclusive: Bobby on the Importance of Focus, the Meaning of Star Power and the Advice He Follows