Food Fight!: Soy Nut Butter vs. Sunflower Seed Butter

soy butter and sunflower seed butter

Food Network Kitchen Soy Nut Butter Healthy Eats Food Network

Photo by: Stephen Johnson ©2014, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Stephen Johnson, 2014, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Which of these alterna-nut butters is the superior pick? Just in time for the back-to-school season, two sandwich spreads battle it out. 

Soy Nut Butter

This spread is made from roasted soybeans, oil and salt. Some brands include extras like palm oil and added sugar. Soy nut butter has a wonderfully thick and creamy texture, but the flavor does come across as a bit stale, leaving a slightly unpleasant aftertaste. (That said, a tasty jam can easily distract from this.)

Nutritionally speaking, soybean-derived butter is comparable to peanut butter. A tablespoon contains 95 calories, 7 grams of total fat (much of it the "good" kind) and a little over 1 gram of saturated fat. The soy butter also delivers 3.5 grams of protein and just 1.5 grams of sugar. Sodium content can vary quite significantly but averages about 50 milligrams per tablespoon. The spread also boasts small amounts of other minerals, including iron and calcium.

Sunflower Seed Spread

Sunflower butter or "sun butter," as this spread is sometimes called, is made from sunflower seeds whirred with sugar, salt and occasionally a drop of oil. We did spot one organic brand made only from seeds and salt. The spread is a bit more oily than soy nut butter -- with a sheeny layer reminiscent of natural peanut butters -- and most brands suggest refrigerating after opening. But the seed butter earns a big thumbs-up in the taste department , with a nutty, well-rounded flavor that makes it a close cousin to peanut butter.

One tablespoon contains 100 calories, 8 grams of fat (again, mostly of the the unsaturated variety) and 0.5 gram of saturated fat. On the protein and sugar fronts, it's neck and neck with soy nut butter, with 3.5 grams and 1.5 grams, respectively. Sodium levels jump around here as well, although 50 to 60 milligrams are the norm. Sunflower butter slightly edges out soy nut butter in the fiber department -- with 3 grams total to soy butter's 1.5 -- and can also claim slightly more iron.

Healthy Eats Winner: Sunflower seed spread comes out on top! Great flavor and a simple ingredient list make it a winning option for kids' (or adults') lunch boxes.

Next Up

Margarine vs Butter: What’s the Difference?

And can you substitute one for the other?

11 Best Flavored Nut Butters, Tested by Food Network Kitchen

We sampled dozens to find the tastiest ones for your sandwiches, sauces and snacks.

Butter Basics

Learn how to navigate all the butters in your supermarket dairy aisle, then find out which applications require the different varieties.

Tamari vs. Soy Sauce: What's the Difference?

Learn the differences and when to use each one.

What Is Cookie Butter?

Learn how to use it, store it and make your own.

Which Is Better for You: Almond Butter or Peanut Butter?

We break down the differences between the two popular nut butters.

The Best Peanut Butters, Tested by Food Network Kitchen

We tasted more than 20 peanut butters to find the best ones for your lunch box.

What’s the Difference Between East Coast Butter and West Coast Butter?

Shocker: butter comes in different shapes based on where you live.

Does Peanut Butter Go Bad?

Peanut butter is a staple for sandwiches, sweet treats, and snacking, but does it expire? Here are the facts.

Should You Refrigerate Peanut Butter?

How quickly can you make it through your jar?