Holiday Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a holiday face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices for holiday baking ingredients.
bleached flour

FNM-Flour-004.tif

©Hearst Communications inc., 2010

Hearst Communications inc., 2010

Food Network Magazine staged a holiday face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices. Before you bake your holiday faves, see how these staples stack up.

Bleached Flour vs. Unbleached Flour

WINNER: It's a draw. The less processed version isn't always the better pick: Unbleached and bleached flour have identical calorie, fiber and protein counts. The FDA regulates the ingredients used to whiten flour, so they're only added in safe amounts. But if you're worried about eating something with the word "bleach" on the label anyway, go the unbleached route.

Raisins

100840261

Raisins

Photo by: Vitali Dyatchenko

Vitali Dyatchenko

Raisins vs Dried Cranberries

WINNER: Raisins. Raisins and dried cranberries have similar amounts of sugar, but all of the sugar in raisins comes from what's naturally present in grapes, while more than half of the calories in dried cranberries can come from sweeteners that manufacturers add to make them taste less tart.

brown egg

100146300

eggs new 21

Photo by: Zeljko Bozic

Zeljko Bozic

Brown Eggs vs White Eggs

WINNER: It's a draw. Nutritionally, white and brown eggs are the same—the color comes from the breed of the hen that laid them. You might assume that brown eggs' higher price tag means they're healthier, but they just cost more because chickens that lay brown eggs are larger and more expensive to feed.

Canola Oil

FNM-OneCupVegOil-005.tif

©Hearst Commmunications Inc., 2009

Hearst Commmunications Inc., 2009

Canola Oil vs Vegetable Oil

WINNER: Canola oil. The stuff labeled "vegetable oil" is most often soybean oil, which is similar to canola oil in terms of fat and calories. But more of canola oil's fat grams come from good fats: It has nearly 50 percent more heart-healthy omega-3s and almost three times as many monounsaturated fatty acids, which have been shown to lower bad cholesterol.

Carob Chips

FNM-CarobChip2-004.tif

Photo by: Ben Goldstein/Studio D ©Hearst Communications Inc., 2012

Ben Goldstein/Studio D , Hearst Communications Inc., 2012

Chocolate Chips vs Carob Chips

WINNER: It's a draw. Carob can be slightly lower in fat, calories and sugar than semisweet chocolate, but the number of chips that end up in any given cookie isn't going to add up to a huge difference. Plus, each tablespoon of semisweet chocolate chips contains about one gram of fiber—some carob chips don't have any.

Our Expert: Takami Kim is a registered dietician with New York–Presbyterian Hospital's Department of Food and Nutrition Management.

(Photographs of Flour and Canola Oil: Marko Metzinger/Studio D., Raisins: David Murray/Getty Images, Carob Chips: Ben Goldstein/Studio D.)

Next Up

Eight Culinary All Stars Face Off in Flavortown

The five-week tournament kicks off on Wednesday, August 16 at 9|8c.

This Walmart Sale Is Officially Kicking Off the Holiday Season

Shop steep savings on thousands of products during the Walmart Deals Holiday Kickoff sale.

The Try Guys Face Off in Kitchens with No Recipes, No Culinary Training and 100% Commitment

No-Recipe Road Trip with the Try Guys premieres Wednesday, 8/31 at 10|9c.

There’s Only One Holiday Drink Starbucks Serves All Over the Globe – Can You Guess Which One?

The coffee chain released a list of 27 festive beverages it serves around the world.

Which Is Healthier: Turkey or Beef Burgers?

Beef burgers get a bad rap for being too high in fat, but turkey burgers can cook up dry and bland. Here's what to know about choosing the best burger.

Which Grocery Stores Are Open on Christmas Day?

Forgot something on your ingredient list? Here’s where to go when you’re in a pinch.

Which Grocery Stores Are Open and Closed on Thanksgiving?

Here's where you can grab any last minute ingredients.

Gluten-Free Holiday Baking

During holiday baking season, those who are sensitive to or intolerant of gluten needn’t miss out on all the sweet seasonal treats.

Which Is Better for You: Almond Butter or Peanut Butter?

We break down the differences between the two popular nut butters.