Should You Drink Bottled Water or Tap Water?

by in Food Safety, Healthy Tips, February 14, 2012
bottled water
Should you spring for bottled, or is tap just fine?

It’s the battle over water! Should you be dropping cash on bottled versions or is tap the way to go? We’re diving into this controversy and sprinkling you with all the facts.

There are different varieties of bottled water, depending on their source. Here is a rundown:

  • Mineral water comes from an underground source and contains a certain amount of minerals and trace element like copper, zinc, and arsenic.
  • Spring water is collected from a spring that flows naturally through the surface.
  • Municipal water comes from a public source that is usually treated before it’s bottled. You may see it labeled as “purified water.”

Having bottled water available when you’re on the go is convenient and less messy (many reusable bottles leak), but recent studies conducted will make any bottle-loving person a skeptic.

According to a 2008 investigation conducted by the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a variety of contaminants were found in every tested brand of bottled water. Although tap water is typically tested annually, bottled water doesn’t have to meet the same testing standards and they don’t have to disclose results of any contaminant testing conducted. After conducting this research, the EWG concluded that the “purity of bottled water cannot be trusted…[and] consumer confidence in the purity of bottled water is simply not justified.”

Also, bottled water has a larger carbon footprint than tap water and doesn’t contain any of the added nutrients found in tap water (like fluoride)—though you can find bottled water that has been fortified with fluoride. the problem is, over-consumption of fluoridated water can lead to fluorosis which causes a brownish discoloration on the teeth. It also costs thousands of times more than tap water.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the U.S. has one of the safest sources of drinking water. In 1974, Congress passed the Safe Drinking Water Act to protect the public by regulating the water supply and protecting its sources. The 3-step process to ensure clean water includes removal of dirt and other particles, filtration to remove clay or natural organic matter, and treatment with chlorine, chlorinates or chlorine dioxides. By law, water suppliers must inform you within 24 hours if your water has become contaminated.

Tap water usually contains a variety of healthy minerals like calcium and magnesium since it travels through rock formations. Fluoride is added to most sources of tap water since the mineral isn’t found in many food sources. It’s beneficial for healthy teeth and bones.

Tap water can also pick up pesticides which have been washed into streams and rivers. Chlorine is added to tap water to help disinfect it, but it can react with fallen leaves to form a toxic byproduct. Even your own pipes can contaminate tap water with lead. The government does test the water regularly to ensure safety. Check the EPA website to find out about your local drinking water.

Those with a low immune systems like transplant recipients, those with HIV/AIDS or undergoing chemo, pregnant women, older adults, children and infants are more sensitive to any issues with the tap water. They’re advised to filter their tap water or to choose bottled versions.

Bottom Line: Don’t be fooled into thinking that bottled water is cleaner or more pure than the good old tap. If you have clean tap water, then save your money and go for it. Bottled water is good for times when you’re in a pinch.

TELL US: Which do you prefer?

You Might Also Like:

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby’s full bio »

More posts from .

Similar Posts

Make Family Meals a Resolution This Year

Family meal doesn't have to be stressful! Try these tips and recipes!...

Comments (357)

  1. tawny says:

    Flouride is not a “nutrient” and is, in fact, a harmful chemical that should not be added to our water supplies.

    • puyallupgal says:

      As a public health measure, fluoridation is unusual in several ways. It is a copy of a naturally occurring phenomenon. It is supported by libraries full of articles that document its safety and effectiveness—more so than any other public health measure. It is supported by a variety of health, scientific, and civic groups that could hardly be expected to agree on any other single measure. But most significant, it is the only health measure that is often put to public vote.If you live in a community with fluoridated water, consider yourself lucky. If you do not, don't let the poisonmongers scare you. Fluoridation is still a modern health miracle.

  2. […] Should You Drink Bottled Water or Tap? […]

  3. miracle water says:

    Widening your knowledge when it comes to the pros and cons of tap and bottled water would help you decide which one you would prefer. You just have to ensured that it would be safe to use. Having an ionized water New York could also give an assurance that you would not be acquiring any disease.

  4. Samara says:

    What about water from your own well??? I have one and would love to hear how it compares to city tap water and bottled

  5. I merely added this great site to my own google reader, excellent goods. Can’t obtain enough!

  6. Fantastic products from a person, man. Khmer Karaoke Stars » Somnangblogs We’ve understand your current stuff earlier than and you happen to be just as well great. I truly like what we have bought here, certainly just like what you happen to be stating and the way you point out it. You help it become entertaining and you still care for to keep it intelligent. I are unable to wait you just read much much more from a person. This is in reality a great Khmer Karaoke Superstars » Somnangblogs data.

  7. Click {Here says:

    I admire the beneficial data you offer as part of your articles and reviews. Ill bookmark your website and have absolutely my kids visit listed here typically. Im fairly sure they will learn a lot of new stuff here than anybody else!

  8. fun says:

    pretty helpful material, overall I feel this is worthy of a bookmark, thanks

  9. da klicken says:

    Categorical gratitude simply for that great suggestions exceptional judgement; that can be whatever actions which stays you in actual fact aside functioning.I possess for retains long been really eager somewhere nearly for your personal web-site perfect after As well as witnessed around these excellent for a following companion alongside with was in truth greatful provides what super food was in that prep to get them advisable right immediately after hunting for period. To become familiar tumblr, Fan satisfied to locate elsewhere the relaxation completing gumption and consequently digging in for which local area. I just now coveted to evaluate to present their enjoyment in your own be able to create as points are specifically shoving, even though satisfactory world-wide-web freelancers can in no way ask for your credit rating these people probably need to ‘ve got. Thus i’m favorable I could give to their office rear and we could send orders out in the open a number of the organization contacts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>