Taste Test: Nonfat Vanilla Yogurt

by in Grocery Shopping, Taste Test, May 12, 2010

vanilla yogurt

Quick, easy, portable and healthy — yogurt is an all-around favorite snack. But with supermarket shelves stacked with the stuff, shopping for yogurt can get confusing. After some tasting and label reading, check out what we found.

The Criteria
For this taste test, we tested all types of nonfat vanilla-flavored yogurts. We focused on taste, mouth feel and nutritional value and scored each on a 5-points scale (5 being highest).

We took a look at the calories and sugar in each yogurt. Since yogurt is made from milk sugar (called lactose), you’ll typically find some natural sugar is in all yogurt. We took a deeper look into the types of sugars (or in some cases sugar substitutes) that were added to yogurt — some even surprised us!

Each yogurt tested contained between 5 to 8 grams of protein and between 15 to 30 percent of your daily calcium needs per 6 ounces. As all dairy products contain sodium, the amount was about the same for all varieties ranging from 75 to 110 milligrams per 6 ounces. Another interesting find is that most yogurt companies add vitamin D which works with calcium to keep bones healthy (check the ingredients and you’ll find “vitamin D3″ listed) — the only exception was Activia Light. All yogurts had active cultures (a.k.a probiotics) added to them although some brands advertised them more than others.

Stonyfield French Vanilla
Rating: 4.5
Cost: $1.00 per 6 ounces
Nutritional info (per 6 ounces): 130 calories, 24 grams sugar
Our Take: The organic yogurt of the bunch, Stonyfield has a creamy texture that is not overly sweet. It’s made from organic nonfat milk and milled organic sugar is added for sweetness —which is why you’ll find that it has the highest sugar content of the bunch. The ingredient list is relatively simple and easy to understand without any added chemicals or artificial sweeteners. Although it was pricier than some of the other varieties, I often find it on sale at my local market.

Weight Watchers Vanilla
Rating: 3
Cost: $0.85 cents per 6 ounces
Nutritional info (per 6 ounces): 100 calories, 12 grams sugar
Our Take: A little more watery than some of the other varieties, Weight Watchers didn’t have that rich and creamy mouth feel. The yogurt is made from nonfat milk and is sweetened with the artificial sweetener sucralose — which explains the aftertaste. A quick look at the laundry list of ingredients reveals added fiber, giving it 3 grams per 6 ounces. Weight Watchers fans take note:  only one point per 6 ounce serving.

Light & Fit Vanilla
Rating: 3
Cost: $0.75 per 6 ounces
Nutritional info (per 6 ounces): 80 calories, 11 grams sugar
Our Take: This yogurt is the lowest in calories and sugars as it’s made from nonfat milk, but it’s sweetened with a combo of sugar substitutes including sucralose and aspartame. For someone who is really trying to cut calories, this may be a good choice if you can deal with the chemical aftertaste. The texture is smooth and somewhat creamy and it was the cheapest of the bunch.

Activia Light Vanilla
Rating: 3.5
Cost: $1.12 per 6 ounces
Nutritional info (per 6 ounces): 110 calories, 13 grams sugars
Our Take: All the ads for this yogurt promote the fact that it’s bursting with several probiotics promising to keep you regular. Although it has a creamy mouth feel, it’s one of the sweetest yogurts of the bunch (compliments of the sugar substitute sucralose). Unlike most of the other yogurts, Activia Light only comes in 4-ounce containers or 24-ounce tubs — as this is the most expensive yogurt, buying the larger container would be a smarter choice. It also contains 4.5 grams of added fiber per 6 ounces, where most other brands contain none.

Yoplait Light Very Vanilla
Rating: 3
Cost: $0.85 per 6 ounces
Nutritional info (per 6 ounces): 110 calories, 15 grams sugar
Our Take: This yogurt is created from nonfat milk and is sweetened with high fructose corn syrup and aspartame. The yogurt was pretty creamy, but as we’ve seen with some of the other varieties, aspartame gives it that chemical-like taste.

TELL US: What’s your favorite yogurt?

Check out our other taste tests:

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby’s full bio »

Similar Posts

Spreading the Joy: Halva Gets a Healthier Makeover

Halva, the Middle Eastern sesame candy, is a dessert favorite. Dense and rich, it tastes like peanut buttery fudge and is often layered with ribbons of chocolate. What could be better? Just one problem: It’s traditionally loaded with sugar. Israeli native Shahar Shamir was a huge halva fan too, but as a former dancer keen onRead more

Comments (69)

  1. Adam says:

    Stonyfield without a doubt is my go-to yogurt brand, for one it’s organic, I stay away from artificial anything, and they have great flavors and great consistency, even the nonfat flavors

    I also like Brown Cow.. also Wallaby Australian style yogurts, they’re a little more runny, but the flavors are great.. also Cascade Fresh, they’re sweetened only with fruit juices

  2. Therese says:

    Fage has spoiled me for any other yogurt. The 2% Cherry is amazing. The full fat strawberry can be eaten in place of cheescake for dessert….yum!!

  3. Joy says:

    The Greek Yogurts are delicious but the flavored has up to 21 gr. of sugar. For the first time eating yogurt I find the plain 0 fat is great but you could add things to it to keep the sugar low.

  4. Sheri says:

    Fage 0% fat plain yogurt with vanilla creme flavored Stevia is my favorite. It is rich and creamy and no added calories with a natural 0 cal. sweetner.

  5. mIchelle says:

    I used to eat Stonyfield Farms. They used to use fruit juice as a sweetener but I cannot find those anymore. Now I am eating Chobani Greek yogurt which is really good. The pineapple is my favorite.

  6. Kyla N says:

    I really like Rachel's brand. Any of the flavors are like having a party in your mouth. They have a nice tang to them.

  7. Carrie says:

    Wouldn't we be better off buying the natural versions instead of the Non-fat yogurts with all of the sugar substitutes? I perfer Dannon Natural vanilla. It probably has more calories but is all natural (which in my mind, is more important).

  8. Mary says:

    I agree, Trader Joes has a great Greek yogurt. But try this: Use any brand non-fat plain yogurt,
    line a strainer with 2 layers of cheesecloth, place over a bowl, spoon the yogurt into the strainer, cover and put in the fridge overnight. In the morning you'll have a wonderful, healthy version of cream cheese to add to cut-up fruit, nuts, whatever and enjoy for breakfast or as an appetizer spread. P.S. Save the whey liquid that collected in the bowl for a healthy addition to your next smoothie!

  9. Mary says:

    I agree, Trader Joes has a great Greek yogurt. But try this: Use any brand non-fat plain yogurt,
    line a strainer with 2 layers of cheesecloth, place over a bowl, spoon the yogurt into the strainer, cover and put in the fridge overnight. In the morning you'll have a wonderful, healthy version of cream cheese to add to cut-up fruit, nuts, whatever and enjoy for breakfast or as an appetizer spread. P.S. Save the whey liquid that collected in the bowl for a healthy addition to your next smoothie!

  10. Scotty says:

    Fage Greek Yogurt is the ultimate best. Look forward to hearing about other Greek yogurts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>