So far in this season of Holiday Baking Championship we’ve seen Joe go home for serving crunchy, pretty much raw apple pie. But this week we saw John go home for a cookie wreath that left the judges wanting more, a lot more, especially in design. John also was in the bottom with Joe back in Episode 1 for an overbaked pie, but it was his use of white chocolate, or what Lorraine called “toothpaste,” that has stayed in the judges’ mind. This week he used “toothpaste” again — not once, but twice — and the judges weren’t fans of it any more than they were the previous week. Relive in GIFs some of the funniest moments with John, the judges and the toothpaste debacle from the series.