Which Is Better: Pie or Cake?

by in News, July 30th, 2014

Which Is Better: Pie or Cake?Dessert confession: I am not a pie person.

Unless it’s Key lime, I can easily pass pie by, even if my disinterest in crusts and cobblers containing apple, cherry, blueberry, pumpkin or (shudder) mincemeat deeply offends my pie-baking mother-in-law. So if you’re serving pie a la mode, just hand me the a la mode, please. But if there’s cake, feel free to give me the biggest piece — and then another.

I am a cake person.

It turns out the world may fall into two distinct groups: pie people and cake people. Recently, representatives from both camps squared off in a battle over bragging rights on Vox.com: “Is cake the great American dessert? Or is it pie?” the site wondered.

“Pie is an American tradition about love and family. Pie is delicious, and complicated, and infinitely better than cake,” Vox’s Kelsey McKinney writes in The Case for Pie, noting that, in literature and on film, pies are often depicted as being worth stealing off windowsills. In addition, she maintains: “Pie is patriotic. You never hear someone say something is ‘as American as cake.’ No. They say ‘as American as apple pie,’ because pies are the most American of desserts. ”

You may feel yourself nodding in agreement (and humming a certain Don McLean song), but before you declare victory for the pie, you owe it to the gods of dessert to allow cake to make its case — or rather to let Alex Abad-Santos argue cake’s case.

“Served at weddings, first birthdays, golden anniversaries, going aways, graduations and holidays, cakes have been the way humans tell other humans they matter,” Abad-Santos notes.

What’s more, he adds: “Regardless of the cake, there’s some wondrous alchemy going on when cake is made. The memories of your mother or father spinning eggs into spongy sweet layers of dough or willing pillowy frosting from sticks of butter are as magical as the cake itself.”

Baked as a rare treat during the Depression or in times of war, cake is a symbol “of American ingenuity and resilience,” he argues. Plus, “Remember: If someone loves you enough to break you out of prison, they do not bake you a pie. They bake you a … cake.”

Clearly, there are claims to be made and strong feelings on both sides of this pressing issue. But there may be no better way to settle the pie-versus-cake debate than in the kitchen.

So, pie lovers, here are 50 pie recipes to help you make your case. And, cake fans, here are a slew of cake ideas — and a helpful how-to on achieving cake perfection every single time.

Get baking. And may the best dessert win.

You tell us now by voting in the poll below.


More posts from .

Similar Posts

This Balletic Beer-Can-Making Video May Make Your Heart Leap

Beer cans and ballet dancers would seem to have little in common — until you watch this unexpectedly graceful video about the making of aluminum bee...

Comments (5)

  1. Bridget says:

    Growing up my Omama made the most spectacular pies–pies you only dream about with the most delicious, well-done NEVER gummy crusts and the most fabulous "not too sweet" fillings: apple, blueberry, cherry, lemon meringue. She ruined pies for me because there will never be another pie that could even compare to the ones she baked. Pie is by far the most delicious and intricate dessert in my opinion and comparing it to cake is like comparing diamonds to oranges! Cake is great BUT pie is divine!

  2. DrummerGrrl says:

    I used to love cake but now I can't stand the sight of it–any cake, any flavor. I developed Type 2 diabetes in 2008 and eating cake makes me feel so wretched that it's just not worth it. Pie, on the other hand…oh, Lord, I LOVE pies! I can't eat a lot of pie, again, because of my diabetes, but sometimes I will find sugar-free pies or turnovers at the local Publix grocery store and then I can indulge my sweet tooth. To be honest, I really don't even miss cake anymore and if I suddenly woke up one day, cured of Type 2 diabetes, I probably wouldn't go back to eating cake.

  3. anna says:

    I like them both as long as they are made well.

  4. woow i love it Great information and best article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>