Seafood vs. Italian: Which Restaurant Divided Concept Did You Like Better?

Restaurant Divided

It was father versus son at Michael's Porthole in Oceanside, N.Y., when Rocco DiSpirito entered the restaurant for the first time. Specializing in seafood, this waterfront eatery was on the brink of closure after a series of devastating accidents and natural tragedies, and while owner Mike Rodonis Sr. was committed to making its fish-focused menu work long-term, his son, Mike Rodonis Jr., who is also the chef at the restaurant, believed that a brand-new Italian concept was needed to jump-start the restaurant's profitability. Rocco had no choice but to divided the space and pursue both ideas before ultimately determining which offered the greatest opportunity for lasting success.

Working with his Restaurant Divided team, Rocco transformed one half of the interior of Michael's Porthole into Mike Jr.'s Il Portello, serving Italian-inspired appetizers, and converted the other half into Mike Sr.'s Canal House Grill, a made-over version of the existing restaurant. Rocco helped both guys tweak their menus to be both business-smart and appealing to customers, then the father and son served separate meals to customers and critics alike. After considering both business' viability and hearing from diners, Rocco announced that the concept of Il Portello is stronger.

Do you think Rocco made the correct decision in choosing Italian over a fish concept, or do you think he should have focused on the fish? Cast your vote below to tell FN Dish which Restaurant Divided concept you liked better.

Next Up

Chipotle Is Opening a New Restaurant Concept, Farmesa

The menu is all about fresh ingredients and bowl customization.

The French Recipe That Divided Julia Child's Kitchen

The second season of Julia explores the drama behind a now-classic dish.

Sashimi Vs Sushi

Two Japanese cuisine experts break down the differences.

Which Is Healthier: Turkey or Beef Burgers?

Beef burgers get a bad rap for being too high in fat, but turkey burgers can cook up dry and bland. Here's what to know about choosing the best burger.

Did You Know You Can Steep Tea Leaves Twice?

In fact, the best flavor often comes from later steeps.

Halwa Tastes Like Sweet Nostalgia

As a child, I used to bite my grandmother’s shoulder until I got a fresh batch of halwa. Now, I prepare it every Diwali.

Which Grocery Stores Are Open on Christmas Day?

Forgot something on your ingredient list? Here’s where to go when you’re in a pinch.

Celebrate Rosh Hashanah Like Molly Yeh

We're not saying there's anything wrong with grandma's brisket, but Molly Yeh sure knows how to spice up holiday favorites.

What Does 2,000 Calories Look Like?

Whether you're an omnivore, vegetarian or vegan, here are 2,000-calorie meal plans.

Which Grocery Stores Are Open and Closed on Thanksgiving?

Here's where you can grab any last minute ingredients.