Judges on the Chopping Block: We Chat With the Round 3 Runner-Up

by in Food Network Chef, Shows, April 21st, 2013

Chopped All-Stars Round 3 JudgesThe tables have been turned. Tonight four judges-turned-competitors, Alex Guarnaschelli, Amanda Freitag, Marc Murphy and Scott Conant, tried their hands at cracking the code on the mystery ingredients in the infamous Chopped baskets. Only one advanced to compete in the third spot in the finale, one step closer to winning $50,000 for his or her charity.

If you missed the show and recorded it, don’t read any further — FN Dish is about to break down the episode and chat with the runner-up.

Amanda FreitagThe Baskets:
Appetizer: Diver scallops, harissa, pink grapefruit and speck
Entree: Capon, ramps, canned pizza sauce and burrata
Dessert: Ruby port, olive oil gelato, dried apricots and French toast sticks

Elimination Details:
Appetizer Round: Marc Murphy
Entree Round: Alex Guarnaschelli
Dessert Round: Amanda Freitag
Winner: Scott Conant

Judges: Aarón Sánchez, Geoffrey Zakarian and Marcus Samuelsson

Chopped judge and All-Stars veteran Amanda Freitag cooked her way to the dessert round against three of her fellow judges and good friends: Marc Murphy, Alex Guarnaschelli and Scott Conant. She wowed everyone by closing out her meal with profiteroles, a Chopped Kitchen first. Despite Amanda’s impressive effort on behalf of her charity, God’s Love We Deliver, Scott irked out a win on the strength of his overall meal. FN Dish talked with Amanda to get the talented runner-up’s take on this intense round of the All-Stars tournament.

Did you feel like your previous All-Stars competition gave you a bit of an edge? Were you more prepared this time?
AF: I felt a little more prepared, but every time you go in there with the clock and the baskets, you never know what’s going to happen. It could be your first time; it could be your hundredth.

Was there any basket ingredient today that you had never worked with before?
AF: No. Every ingredient I had previous experience with. I think all the baskets were really fair and really wonderful little gifts. The frozen French toast was a little evil. I think it was an inside joke.

What was your favorite dish you produced today?
AF: Ironically, I really loved my capon. It just couldn’t beat Scotty’s.

What was the hardest round?
AF: Probably the appetizer round. Everybody was really nervous; getting it done in 20 minutes is just really hard. We had to deal with the diver scallops — shuck them, clean them. That was a lot of labor for the first round. Then you had to make a plate. It was a lot. We all went in not knowing what to expect and it was a challenge. They were just warming us up with that basket.

In the dessert round, Geoffrey said you’d upstaged the souffles and commended you for making profiteroles for the first time in the Chopped Kitchen. Did you have that idea in your back pocket going in to dessert?
AF: I had a few basic desserts in mind that I’m comfortable with and they’re all very different. There were not a lot of ideas that were going to fit with that basket because there was already premade ice cream, already the premade French toast. I truly wanted to make ice cream no matter what I did. I thought a profiterole was a great way to encase everything in one little vehicle.

You said you’re looking forward to having your own dining room again soon. Do you think anything from today would ever end up on your menu?
AF: I may have profiteroles on my menu! I also loved the combinations on the scallops — the harissa with the buttery scallop; the speck with the grapefruit.

Scott said from the first round you were the one to beat for him. Who among the four was the one to beat for you?
AF: I definitely thought Alex was going to be somebody that I’d have to keep my eye on. She has a lot of practice competing as of late. She’s a fierce competitor; she knows her way around that kitchen, and she knows her way around lots of different styles of food. She’s got tons of experience and that makes a big difference. And I love her food, as well.

You haven’t won one of these yet. Are you going to keep at it? Do you enjoy competing?
AF: You know what? The adrenaline is pretty intense. When it first starts happening, I think, “Why am I doing this?” But I am not going to give up. If an opportunity comes my way to compete, I’m going to continue to compete. I’m just lucky to have the opportunity to do so. It’s an interesting forum; it’s not something that everybody gets a chance to do, and I think you grow after every competition you do.

You all know each other so well on All-Stars — both the chefs judging you and your fellow competitors. Do you think it makes it more of a friendly competition or even more intense?
AF: I think it makes it harder. A lot of anguish in the room! I remember two years ago when I first competed on All-Stars, this had never happened before. I remember looking into Alex’s eyes as she was beginning to give me criticism about a plate and it was just painful. It was much more painful to sit there and judge. Then I had the experience to judge on the next season of All-Stars and I understood it. It has come back around and I still think it’s just as hard. They had a tough decision and I did not envy them. At the end point in the day, Scott and I both felt really good and no matter what happens, we’re really cool with it. Scott did it, got it under his belt — he was avoiding this for a long time. And I had a goal of getting into the dessert round and I got there. I made something that I was proud of.

More Amanda Freitag:

Similar Posts

Get Classic Southern Eats in Alabama — On the Road with The Great Food Truck Race

This week on The Great Food Truck Race, the route took the teams to Alabama. On their first day Tyler had the teams getting their hands dirty — pick...

Comments (26)

  1. Wanda Gonzalez says:

    I just saw Chopped where Scot Conant won!! WHY, LOL!!! He is the FIRST to say, FOLLOW RULES, you forget an ingredient, you are OUT!! What happened with the appetizer!!! He's a great chef, of course, all are, I don't agree with the judges decision!!

    I love the show, keep up the good job!
    Thank you

    • Gail says:

      You were an awesome competitor Amanda and it's great that you brought awareness to God's Love We Deliver. Even though you didn't win, we know you're amazing chef and can't wait to see you back in a restaurant!!

    • M. Walker says:

      He didn't forget an ingredient, he forgot something he wanted to add. Onions were not in the basket.

    • The red onion was not part of the basket – so he only forgot an ingredient that he added on his own – not the same

    • JoJo198 says:

      You are so right Wanda, however, see my post below…it was so clear from the beginning that in Jeffrey Z's eyes…Scott could do no wrong……and he had strong enough influence over the other 2 to allow Scott to win. HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN CALLED OUT IN ROUND ONE!!!!

      • Chfan1 says:

        I disagree. I think that Geoffrey really wanted Amanda to win because she is one of his best friends. He was pro-Amanda and did not want to chop her. The NIC and this episode of Chopped was emotionally difficult for him.

      • Karlyn says:

        Geoffrey Z has eyes for Alex. Mouthy Murphy was a good call in round 1.

    • Koreen says:

      Red onion was not in the basket. Perhaps you should view it again

  2. Pam says:

    I love Amanda! She comes across as being fun, warm and classy.

  3. M. Walker says:

    I believe the article should be corrected as follows:.

    "Scott irked out a win on the strength of his overall meal" should be " Scott eked out a win on the strength of his overall meal"

    • MoHub says:

      You are right, but evidently one no longer has to know how to write before placing his or her scribblings before the public.

  4. Woman3434 says:

    My two favorites wound up going against each other, but I'm glad, overall, Scott won:). People were giving him such a hard time when they first announced the All-Star competition, but he backed up his arrogant know-it-all attitude I guess, lol. I have always liked Scott, but to me he isn't as arrogant as Geoffrey.

  5. JoJo198 says:

    It was so clearly evident from Round One at the Chopping Block who was going to win. Jeffrey Z couldn't be more obvious.

  6. David says:

    Amanda — you were amazing. Thank you for all that you do — your charity was well represented and your dishes were amazing. There were no losers on that episode!!!

  7. ritach2 says:

    Marc should have not been the first to go. Alex had too much acid and undercooked meat. Marc got chopped because he needed a sauce. Ugh! I knew Amanda would move up to the top just as she should have in the Iron Chef Competition. She is a much better chef than Alex…heck they are all better than Alex..lol. Am happy for Scott. He was fun to watch. I should note: Alex was not yelling, "get out of my way" this go around. Some progress toward being a bit more respectful toward others.

  8. Annie says:

    Amanda is such a class act. She is a better person than me because at this point, I'd just quit competing.

    I didn't really have an issue with Geoffrey. To me it seemed that Marcus was reluctant to give any praise to anything Amanda did. It seemed only in the end when they were doing a recap of the overall meal that he had something good to say. Something about the textures or depth in her sauce.

  9. Ohio Chick says:

    Amanda was robbed! Her overall meal was superior to Scott's in so many ways. His arrogance alone should've been enough to get him chopped.

  10. Ima says:

    INHO…for four experienced chefs, the baskets were not that difficult. I was hoping that Chef Amanda would win but when I saw the judges…I knew the outcome!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>