Restaurant Revisited: Frankie’s

by in Shows, September 5th, 2012

Robert Irvine at Frankie's on Restaurant: Impossible

When Robert Irvine visited Frankie’s in Three Rivers, Mich., he found a dusty, outdated restaurant with dangerous levels of food safety and a kitchen stocked with more microwaves than pots and pans. After meeting owners Jay Woehrmyer and Tina Wyman, however, he realized that poor management and a lack of leadership were their biggest problems. Robert had just two days to turn around this 13-year-old restaurant and attempt to fix Jay and Tina’s failing partnership. We checked in with Jay and Tina to find out how they and Frankie’s are doing a few months after their Restaurant: Impossible experience.

Since Robert left, sales at Frankie’s have risen 39 percent, and Jay and Tina report that the makeover is attracting new customers. Both count the new open layout of the restaurant among their favorite parts of the decor.

The kitchen staff is adjusting well to Robert’s popular new menu, and Frankie’s is now serving daily specials. They’re no longer serving the mussels, rib-eye and walleye as customer demand wasn’t high enough to keep ingredients fresh.

The owners have taken Robert’s food-handling suggestions to heart. They now ensure that their products are fresh and that raw and precooked items don’t mix. Though the restaurant still uses the pizza oven to prepare many of its dishes, it is no longer as dependent upon its collection of microwaves, relying on them mostly “to keep food warm” and to cook burritos.

Perhaps most importantly, Jay and Tina have taken steps to improve their professional relationship. As Jay’s wife, Debbie, told us, “they still have their ups and downs. But they are communicating with each other instead of intentionally ignoring one another. Robert did a good job pointing out that working together is what is needed to keep the restaurant running.” The pair now meet twice a week to discuss the business, and both owners say that Restaurant: Impossible has changed their partnership for the better.

More From Restaurant Revisited:

Gusanoz (August 29)

Stella’s (August 8)

Italian Village (August 1)

Zandi’s (July 25)

The Main Dish (July 18)

Longbranch Steak and Seafood (July 11)

Horton’s Kids (June 13)

Pollard’s (May 30)

University Grill (May 23)

Ristorante Barolo (May 16)

Pappas (May 9)

Mama Lee’s (May 2)

Pelican Grill (April 25)

Valley View (March 14)

Similar Posts

“Get Ready to Be Blown Away” — Valerie Bertinelli Speaks Out About Kids Baking Championship

Find out what mentor and judge Valerie Bertinelli had to say in our interview with her about Kids Baking Championship, the competition's challenges, t...

Comments (78)

  1. TIMFOODREVIEW13 says:

    April 20, 2013. Drove 120 miles round trip to dine at Frankie's in Three Rivers. Drove up, parking lot was slightly full. Good Sign. Once entered, we stood and after a few minutes someone finally came up and seated us. Our waitress didn't know the menu, had never tried any of the dishes. She took our order. Our appetizer was served before our drinks. An associate waitress made sure our dirty dishes were removed. Our main course was delicious and well worth the trip. Service was poor. Waitress didn't have much training. The owner went to many tables circled us but never stopped to say hello. After such a drive just to visit their restaurant it would of been nice to share what a thrill it was to dine at his estabishment. I thanked the associate waitress for her great service, since she was the one that mainly took care of us. Would we go again? Yes for the food but not NOT the service.

  2. Spot on with this write-up, I truly think this website needs rather more consideration. I’ll in all probability be again to read much more, thanks for that info.

  3. Dogwalker says:

    Frankie's was much, much better years ago when Dave was managing the restaurant. Went there once since the show and was not impressed. Not on my list of favorite restaurants.

  4. Bryan Rawlings says:

    Have been to Frankie's many times before the makeover and 5 times since. Have had a great meal every time since makeover and good service, will continue to go back. Good work Frankie's!

  5. Steve says:

    The wife and I decided to try Frankies the other night since we hadn't been there in several years and saw the show. The food was awful and will not return. I had the all you can eat fish. I couldn't even finish the first serving. The fish was of poor quality and greasy.

  6. Vicki says:

    My favorite show, I love it !!!

  7. says:

    wew, Spot on with this write-up, I truly think this website needs rather more consideration. I’ll in all probability be again to read much more, thanks for that info.

  8. but… Frankie's has good Pizza too ;)

  9. Dan says:

    I have been to Frankies several times over the past few years. Once within a week of the show being there, Once about 6 months after the show aired, and again about 2 weeks ago. On our first visit, I was impressed. Just disappointed that the items that were Chef Robert's recipes that my girls wanted to try were no longer available. The second time I went, the atmosphere had begun to regress, back to the same as when I was there before.
    This past time I went, other than the wall paint, light fixtures, decor, you would never guess the show had been there. Not one item left on the menu from the show. TVs back up all over the walls, especially in the bar area. And the atmosphere was right back to what it used to be, just a typical small town bar. At this point, the only reason I will go back to Frankies, is if my girls and I want to watch a movie at the theater nearby and aren't in the mood for fast food.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>