Font Size:
- A
- A
- A
E-mail This Page to Your Friends
x397 Comments
Post a Comment
Categories
Archives
Newest Comments
On Comfort Food Showdown: All..., angie said:
I never tire of mac and cheese recipes. Keep 'em coming!
Recently Commented On:- Comfort Food Showdown: All... — 2 comments
- Worst Cooks in America.... — 59 comments
- Big Daddy is in... — 24 comments
- Ask Susie - Finale! — 1125 comments
Thank you Susie for acknowledging that integrity is more important than camera presence.
You've got to be kidding………………nice post Susie…….I'll stick with watching the other shows from now on………………………..
Nice BS about the 'rigged' challenge. Taking any bias out of the equation as you suggest Debbie still had the easiest challenge…by far.
As far as your comment about integrity being more important than on screen presence why don't you back up your words with actions?
Thank you Susie for acknowledging that integrity is more important than camera presence. well then DEBBIE cannot win can she?
and YES Debbie had the easiest test, the others did have a harder test
Disarm the critics by starting off with a smile and joking about the Debbie show suggestions.
Don't mention the cabers lie - 3 lies actually, in the dressing, didn't have and when confronted at judging - lied again and said I said "my bad" when she said my bad only after being forced to owning up.
Smug one word answers Does integrity matter YES
Well any 8 year old can tell you that actions speak lounder …
I am truly disappointed in Susie, now the vlog is a waste of time.
Thanks, Susie. If Food Network REALLY believes that integrity is more important than camera presence we can all breathe a deep sigh of relief. That means that integrity challenged (putting it in the kindest way possible) Debbie is not the next Food Network star!
Oh please. Did you ever think that maybe Debbie DOESN"T win the compeition? Of course Susie can't say that Debbie gets kicked off this Sunday, so she's giving one word answers!! Duh!
In the end — THIS IS TV PEOPLE! I know, I for one tune in just to see what lie Debbie will say next. Now, I agree….if she gets picked….it's a whole other story.
But why is everyone getting their panties in a wad when it's not over? And why can't anyone but me see through Susie's obvious "mums the word" comments???
Ok. My blood pressure is starting to go down after this post Susie. BUT live up to your words… if Debbie does NOT go home this Sunday, all faith is lost.
I wouldn't be so sure. Did you hear how she talked about debbie in the rigged challenge?
Mixed messages.
Richard
I see your points, but come on DL should have been eliminated weeks ago and that does get my panties in a wad.
I must say Susie, sarcasm does not become you (it is rarely becoming) and is a disservice to everyone. If it bothers you that much to answer viewer issues why the v-blog? You criticized Jamika for her attitude and then exhibit condescending attitude towards your audience. Something does not compute and in fact is a turn off as you can see from the previous comments.
After the proposed titles for Debbie's program, Susie replied "they speak for themselves". No, they spoke for thousands! This tells me that viewer input isn't valued. It seems as if neither Susie nor Bob are listening. It's all pre-recorded and rigged, anyway. Perhaps a Phone-in-to-vote ala dance programs would work toward viewers opinions truly meaning something.
Do any of the contestants who didn't win the challenge get a program? Probably …. Debbie! Surprise, surprise …
I here you, KDM. She should have gone weeks ago, that is very true.
But, do you think anyone else that has been kicked off so far deserved a chance at the final two? NOT saying that Debbie deserves a shot, but I definitely don't think anyone else that got booted deserves that spot. I DO think that if Jeff and Melissa go to the last episode then that IS the right choice.
Just curious…..
What a way to skir the issue. But isn't it obvious, people? Debbie is the winner of this show and this is what you call 'Damage Control'. How ignorant do you think the viewers are? Debbie's rigged task was far from the horror that the other 2 contestants were faced with. And you know what made it worse…watching Debbie laughing at Melissa. I still see that image of her face and it just irritates me like you cannot believe. Really ope you ditch the Debbie show and stick with Jeffrey (or even Melissa, who is way too Mommy and Me but far outweighs Debbie).
Integrity is far more important than camera presence. Fans will more like follow someone they trust. I think Debbie tried to hard to be perfect, and does not realize that fans actually prefer someone with a bit of fault. There have been to many instances where she is trying to make herself look better than the rest by planting a white lie. I think she set the stage in the very first challenge by overspending , then backtracking and saying that she was able to get everything she needed. Most of the personalities on Food Network are successful because fans trust them. When they see them at events, they want to talk to them. They want to get to know them. In Debbie case, she might be good at what she does, but I would not be interested at all about getting to know her. Branding mistrust is not what Food Network is about.
Agree. Debbie's challenge WAS much easier.
BUT, I think Susie has a smug attitude because she knows something we don't. It's almost like somebody right before Christmas teasing about a gift that they MAY or MAY NOT have gotten for someone. Of course she can't TELL US what's in that present that we'll open this Sunday….but my gut feeling is that it's going to be an eliminated Debbie Lee all wrapped up in a pretty pink ribbon.
Kathy. Please see previous comment I made to Valerie.
I think Susie isn't being rude, she's foreshadowing.
HA! My gut says yes. To DTK being kicked off, not hit by a bus rather. LOL
And thats why I not on the boycott wagon. As much as I love Jamika, she has been out of sorts for a while now. I do think Michael could have been worked with though.
Yes — Debbie may pull one out of the bag once in a while, but I agree with many — why has she been allowed to continue so long when she has obviously shown who she is? She should have been eliminated at the last challenge where she proved — again, she is not forthright (that's nice for A LIAR!) Why would you choose to elinate Jamika for her shortcoming of being inflexibe and emotionally reactive, that at least could be addressed with some coaching — and ignore a major character flaw like lack of integrity that Debbie has shown time after time? She is not authentic either — and the camera picks that up. Please get this competition back on track!
It is obvious Gina. But you are reading Susie correctly!! Why would Susie say that integrity is more important than camera precence if DTK was NOT going to be kicked off?
That would be dumb…now I know what you're going to say, "Food Network has been dumb all along because they have kept her on this long." Yes, I agree. But I also know that I keep watching because of Debbie even though I hate her. (or at least strongly not like). And at the end of the day isn't that what tv corporate people want us to do? keep watching?
I doubt that they would edit a show showing all of debbies lies and not kick her off at the last minute.
Jeffery and Melissa are the best and they BOTH made it to the final two? I think the judges will get it right. Personally Jeffery is so much better than Mellissa.but both are okay.
OOPPPS! I meant you are reading Susie INCORRECTLY.
Freudian slip. LOL!!!
Sorry Susie but you really copped out on this one - If FN believes integrity is more important than camera presence Debbie would have been gone form the get go - And even with the bias against Debbie aside - she did receive the easiest of the chanllenges so it was not surprising that whe handled it the best. i would have liked to see how she would have handled the same challenge that either Jamika or Jeffrey were given…
Dislike for Debbie and an imbalance in the difficulty of the challenges have nothing to do with each other. you chose the challenges long before we ever knew about Debbie.
I daresay if Debbie had been the one having issues with the host or cameraman, she'd have blamed them with an attitude far outweighing Jamica's. THERE. THAT'S a biased opinion. Fork vs. meddling host with a bottle of hot sauce? Hardly.
It's good to know integrity outweighs camera readiness. My question is: when will you be demonstrating that?
Susie's smug reponse tells me that Debbie is going home, or these blogs are a huge waste of our time and they could not care less for our opinions. Either way, the way they have handled this has really cooled my enthusiasm for the FN altogether and I will be looking elsewhere for cooking shows.
This has been one of the worst selections as far as the next Food Network Star. I really did not think anyone could be worst than "Big Daddy" But you have done it. I agree witht eh fans that you are rigging this contest - What a shame to treat your loyal viewers so bad.
As you get closer to the end how much is weighted on all performances not just the last challenge? Since the winner has already been decided, if it is Debbie and she is so much more unpopular than you could have anticipated how will you deal with this?
Sharon,
When Susie said, "they speak for themselves" she wasn't saying that those titles are just the opinion of those who shared them, she was saying that the titles are so expressive and so correctly sum up the situation, that she (Susie) doesn't have anything to add to it.
I don't like Debbie either but aren't we all taking this a little too seriously? I can perfectly understand Susie's "attitude" when instead of real questions, it is all "I hate Debbie" blah, blah, blah.
This is my first year watching the show and I have really enjoyed it. I look forward each week to the next episode to see what is going to happen next. Isn't that really what TV entertainment is all about?
Sorry but this Debbie crap is getting old, even though, as I stated above, I don't like her either and I don't get what the FN judges see in her.
Debbie would always be able to deal with a rigged challenge. The part of the brain used in improvising is also the part used for lies. Some one used to lying is well verse in wingging it. She lives her life that way…
You are right the Debbie stuff is getting old and I think that is why people are so fired up about it. She should have been gone the first show. As I said before, the shenanigans can stop. The last seasons were much better. Have them trained on TV and then challenge their training. I also love watching and hoping Melissa wins and hoping that Debbie does not, mostly because she does not deserve it. Aaron McCargo deserved it and he has a great show and I have cooked his food its great too![polldaddy 1808739 http://answers.polldaddy.com/poll/1808739/ polldaddy]
Sorry, Susie, I don't buy it. Clearly Debbie has won, and you're just trying to prepare us all. I have totally lost faith in the Food Network; in addition to the way the judges have handled this program, I've noticed that when I watch a program and then go to download the recipe, often the online recipe does not match the program! The quantities are different, the techniques are different, and I can only conclude that the chefs either don't want us to succeed at making their precious recipes or that no one checks them. Sorry to tell you you've lost me as a viewer, but I doubt that you care.
Susie, I have to disagree….I think your bias for Debbie equals, if not exceeds, my bias against her. The lying is only one issue, it is what she was lying about that is the fundamental problem I have with her…apparently you can lie, and repeatedly, to the selection committee and move on, but Jamika's blunt, honest reaction simply cannot be tolerated.
And can you honestly, honestly tell me that if Jeffrey had not used the blueberries in his state challenge that he would have moved on…as Debbie did with her non use of the capers?…I cannot understand why you even give specific ingredients to be used when you have clearly shown that the use of said ingredients is optional.
Susie:
You inevitably disappoint folks when you show them how the sausage is made.
Here's to this season's wiener!
I went to Red Lobster and ate Jefery's dish. I usually do not eat scallops or talapia but it was great. i loved it. Every will like Jefery after they eat it. Try the new dish that is on the fresh fish menu at Red Lobster.[polldaddy 1808795 http://answers.polldaddy.com/poll/1808795/ polldaddy]
I won't watch either of the finalist who becomes the next food net work star.
i especially won't watch Mellissa, I think she will be boring. Everybody already know her little tips.
You should not have gotten rid of Jameka she would have been new and refreshing to watch. Debbie lies too much to cover her self. At lease Jameka was honest.
Your poll is not showing up, but I clicked the link and voted anyway. My problem with polldaddy is that it doesn't say how many people voted.
Lol! Agreed, Bill! Couldn't have said it better myself!
I don't like Debbie also, I think that she is so fake if FN doesn't send her home I will never watch FN again.
Everyone knows that Debbie has no integrity and that turns off everyone from liking her. I think that if FN cares about it's viewers they would eliminate Debbie Liar immediately.
I agreed
Please don't hate me I'm Korean.
Yeah, I'm getting tired of the whole Debbie kerfuffle.
I can't begin to tell you how angry I am at FN and Susie Fogelson. There is nothing about Debbie that anyone would want to watch. No matter what you say Susie,,,,YOUR WRONG IN YOUR JUDGEMENT AND HAVING DEBBIE THE WINNER!!!! Debbie shouldn't have made it this far. I too will stop watching FN as the judging is SOOOOO UNFAIR.
Oh, dear. I feel quite chastised now. Thanks, Mother Susie. I feel as if I have been spoken to as if I were two years old. Not a good thing. No, no. Not a good thing. If you are VP of Marketing, you are rapidly alienating a large, large audience. No, not a good thing.
If you're so good at your job and knowing what's marketable, then you should know that no one wants to watch Debbie. She's already been on 2 episodes too many.
Bill, I love how you write! Well put!
i am tooo
Oh.
No one liked my title for Debbie's new show - I thought should be co-hosted with ROBERT IRVINE?
"PANTS ON FIRE"
I thought it was pretty good. Darn.
Last year, Jag was kicked off due to credibility issues yet Debbie who lies (repeatedly) to the judges stays. FN booted Robert from DI but had to bring him back when Michael flopped (Robert was much better anyway). If credibility matters, make it matter. I have a feeling that Debbie is still around for the "drama" but will be leaving us soon.
I have to say that Debbie does seem shady at times, but so does Jeff. Did you watch the longer arguments section that went down after the Miami fiasco? Jeff basically laid all the blame onto Debbie and tried to act all holy than thou. "I got my dishes done a half hour early" - Oh yeah, then how come they had to set them up all evening. Also - Jeff tried to control everything throughout all the 2hrs of cooking and stuff and then he and sheman ran off together to play at the party and gave some brief 3 min instructions to Jamika and Melissa.
I mean seriously, that's how you're going to play it? Jeff assigned the biggest part of the night to Debbie and he went and shmoozed. It takes a lot of "talent" to hand food out to people. I mean… who loves you people… Jeff and Mike didn't even show Debbie how to "plate" their nasty food anyway.
Sorry FNP but Guy is one of the most dynamic personalities on the network and actually has the chops to prove it. From day one on Season 2, he showed that he was head and shoulders above the rest of the contestants. You may not like him but he's no joke.
FN and Susie Fogelson are begining to look just as fake as Debbie Lee. I hear sarcasm in Susie Fogelson voice. I think that Debbie' s attitude is beginning to rub off on the judges as well. Ordinary people sharing their cooking skills on youtube are much more entertaining to watch then those on FN. FN is going down hill and with hosts like Debbie Lee - We'd just have to bid FN… Hasta la vista!! Give Debbie Lie oops! *Lee* the BOOT!!!! And, don't let the door hit her on the way out!
If the caterer can't control the prep area then they are a sucky caterer. She didn't plate their food because she was spending all her time on her dishes.
I'd rather know what's in the sausage than be suprised with the preservatives later
She's not on the competition to be a caterer. If I had been in Jeff's position I would have been in back helping to plate things up when food wasn't coming out. Instead he just wandered around and then blamed Debbie for everything.
I like what Debbie has to offer. I don't want another Mexican cooking show. I don't want another Sandra Lee.
I thought Adama should have won last year - Instead foodnetwork stole his show idea and gave it to some chick- and he still gets a show.
If Debbie doesn't win- I hope she gets a show anyway because it'll be better to watch than Jeff or Melissa - bland.
If you don't already watch it, let me suggest PBS. In my area the cooking shows are on Saturday late morning and afternoon. So much better than anything you'll see on FN. More like FN was when it started. (Even Mario Batali has "gone over" to PBS)
DRH-thanks for the suggestion- I will!
Susie, I have enjoyed reading and sometimes adding my two cents to these messages. I hope, if there is a next season, you and Bob keep these blogs going. I don't know if you take any of our comments seriously, but it sure has given a lot of folks a place to vent frustrations. That may not have been your intent, but it certainly seems to work that way.
I can't wait to see what happens Sunday night, and isn't that the whole point, more viewers means higher ratings.
Integrity (noun) 1. Steadfast adherence to a strict moral or ethical code. 2. Considtency of actions, values,methods, measures and principles. Integrity may be seen as the quality of having a sense of honesty. American Heritage Dictionary; en.wikipedia.org/wiki/integrity
The above is for Susie the Spinmeister and the rest of the folks at FN who will no doubt continue to wag the dog. If Debbie as TNFNS doesn't work out for them, I think they've already proved that they are well qualified for careers in politics.
They carried Aaron through last year. When he should have been. He got the easy challenge in vegas and performed worse during elimination. So what happens they don't eliminate anyone.
And I did ask a couple of questions. Lots of people did as well Susie just ignored them.
I hope next week you will stop being so condescending towards viewers who are the ones keeping you in business. Don't accuse people of bias when you clearly have an agenda of your own. And any bias there has been created by what FN itself has has shown.
Last year you carried/pushed Aaron through. We can only imagine that you are doing the same with Debbie this time.
I have just watched your reply to viewer comments. You stated that 'camera presence does not outweigh honesty and integrity and the core values of the Food Network', yet Debbie is still here. Why is that? In addition, you referred to those of us that don't care for Debbies dishonesty, collectively as biased. A definition of bias states the lack of abilty to be unprejudiced or objective. Since the word prejudice can be broken down into two words: Pre + Judge, referring to us as biased is inaccurate and slanderous since she was not pre judged at all. Our opinions were formulated based on her actions. Once she has proven herself a liar, of what more important characteristic are we supposed to remain objective about? Debbie is bad news. I realize that by you and Bob's continual defence of her, since the episodes have already been completed, you are in all liklihood just defending your already selected Next Food Network Star. That said, just because you forfeited your integrity by condoning Debbies lack of it, don't put us down for calling you on it.
What is all the fuss about? I like Debbie and I like Susie. i don't get you folks. I also like Melissa and Jeff - these finalists are all good and could handle their own show.
You have proven to us that honesty does not count. I truly hope you and the other judges choke on Debbie.
Jeffrey did show Debbie how to plate his food–it was on the show. He even had a method of cutting his chicken bites with the skewers already in place to speed up the process.
jeffrey is the only finalist who is even remotely interesting. at least he does not grate on my nerves like debbie the liar and melissa the intense.
Susie,
I know you just went over this, but I have no idea how there is even a show anymore. You are down to 1 contestant that is viable and the only one I will turn to and watch. If Debbie makes it beyond next week I will be very surprised and upset (though I realize this is already said and done), and will probably not not watch NFNS anymore. Debbie is dishonest and even my 12 y/o son picked up on that. Then you have Mr Personality (who I started out liking) that is about as fun to watch as The Neeleys on camera love (Gag), so that leaves one! Pretty easy choice to me!
Even if Debbie leaves this week her tenure has reflected very, very badly on the judges. Their message has been that dishonesty and selfishness is acceptable if you are (supposedly) "camera ready". I sometimes wonder if the judges are watching the same Debbie we are. I find her charmless and conniving. The judges swoon over her chattering and inane patter.
I understand sarcasm coming from commenting viewers but not from a professional newar the top of the FN food chain. I appreciate you might be feeling bombarded but perhaps complete emotioal transparency is best avoided.
Remember, Jamika was counseled about that.
Remember that this was filmed at the beginning of the year and we can voice all are complaints but it is already a done deal. I suspect Debbie does NOT win and they edited the shows to give us a "villain" to build the suspense watching the program. Jamika showed a side of her on the last program that would NOT be a fun person to work with, just as Debbie has behind the scene issues that would make her a hard to deal with "star"
Integrity is incredibly important. Honesty, integrity and working with others. This season is not nearly as good as others - the challenges are a bit flat and things we've seen before. I'm not sure I'll watch the new show that comes out. Not impressed. Last season was much more interesting to watch. Make it where the fans can vote again instead of it being so controlled by the few who are doing so.
Korean has nothing to do with it. Are you a liar? If not… we like you! It's the LYING that is upseting everyone… Korean is KOOL!
I hope Debbie is on her way out. She does have a nice personality to watch, but she shot herself in the foot when she lost the audience's trust….all the camera presence in the world can't buy loyalty if an audience feels lied to.
That said: my vote is for Jeffrey. I'd be interested in a show by him if he could actually bring us recipes from countries not already covered on FN, I love Morrocan cooking, for instance, or real Mediterranean cooking. Enough with the Mexican/spicy….Bobby Flay's got that covered and there are other parts of the world we'd love to experience.
I find this season a great disappointment! As an FN fan I must admit that I am now at a loss as to what to think. I am reminded that the only thing that we truly have to call our own is integrity and yet that apparently has no longer been extended to the FN. When Debbie first blundered with truth I thought "maybe she was nervous and just blurted out something not meaning to lie". But I have seen a pattern that makes it unbearable to watch and the pattern of stretching the truth if you will and blaming others is really unattractive. As Bob has said before, people have to connect with the next Food Network star and clearly I am not alone that the level of trust or connectability is NOT there with Debbie. She should have been sent home weeks ago and the others that have been eliminated before her should have moved on to try to improve; they were coachable but integrity isn't. Once trust is lost, it is gone… Susie, stop shaming your fans and stop and listen. We are not kids and perhaps on the other side of the camera we are seeing something that you are obviously missing. Shame on you!!!
Maybe the "FN Dish" title is also an urban slang language description of what the network is trying to do with us now.
Integrity was an issue with Teddy and Eddie, why? Because they weren't who you wanted. Debbie, an Asian (and under-represented on your shows), with a great on screen presence, has perhaps worse integrity issues but she's still there. So, no, Susie, integrity does not top on camera presence with you guys. It does only when its easy.
BTW I watched the preview of the next show and Debbie has an on camera blurb where she says, showing no remorse whatsoever, that she's had a few lapses in judgment but she's gonna strive to still win this thing. In whose universe is that half-mea culpa going to satisfy anybody.
I've been looking forward to these challenges all along, and I've found myself — after watching that preview with her "lapses in judgment" comment that I'm losing my joy in watching the food channel. I guess I'll always watch Ina, even Debbie can't ruin her for me, but it's no longer my "go to" station just to see what's on. That's sad.
But I love that so many care so deeply about integrity and that it bugs them. It says a lot about who we are as a people.
Sorry, Susie. I don't buy it. Even taking out the Debbie-bias, she had the easiest challenge. Any cook whose children have put away the dishes has dealt with "missing utensils", and if you've grocery shopped in a time crunch with a tantrum-throwing 3-year-old, you've likely had to work with a "wrong" ingredient. I have never, however, had to deal with someone dumping random stuff in my food or sticking cameras/mikes in my face while I was cooking.
Susie: Just remember that if Debbie wins you will have to contend with her for the duration of her shows that nobody will be watching.
Do your soponsors realize this? Surely it is not too late for you to pick a winner that will be good for FN's reputation.
For me. this weeks show will be the decider. If the two finalists are not Jeff and Melissa, then this series is off the list permanently. I am simply too old to waste time hoping that their will be 'value' in something eventually. Will next years TNFNS adjust to correct this years mistakes, it will not matter if Debbie Lee moves to the final two. You will have cut one of the two reasonable contestants in order to put in a demonstrably bad one.
For me. this weeks show will be the decider. If the two finalists are not Jeff and Melissa, then this series is off the list permanently. I am simply too old to waste time hoping that there will be 'value' in something eventually. Will next years TNFNS adjust to correct this years mistakes, it will not matter if Debbie Lee moves to the final two. You will have cut one of the two reasonable contestants in order to put in a demonstrably bad one.
Debbie Ugh. Enough said.
I just watched your video and you said that integrity does matter. If that is the case then I feel like we are being played by the producers of food network star by using Debbie to stir up this controversy truth over taste. If you do choose Debbie then I will not watch Food network star again because I don't appreciate manipulation in any form. I can promise I will never watch her show if she is chosen. This whole season has seemed to me to have very weak contenders with perhaps only two choices. Certainly there were far more talented foodies who entered that would have made this much more competitive.
Debbie's caused a lot of controversy. I've called for her removal, too. We're being manipulated. Controversy = Ratings. Ratings = Money. Perhaps they figure if they keep Debbie until the very end, we'll keep watching JUST to see if she becomes the NFNS. I mean, if Debbie had been sent home two weeks ago, would we still be making certain we didn't miss an episode to finally see her get kicked off? Or, would we haunt these boards to check out the interviews, blogs, etc.? Then, at the end, perhaps she'll be sent home and FN can stand on their high horses and say: "See, we TOLD you so. Integrity DOES TOO matter."____Haven't all these episodes been taped and in the can for weeks, now? If so, they know who won even before the first episode was aired. So, all this time they've been cutting and pasting what they show during each episode just to build controversy about Debbie just to make sure we watch.____Right now the VP of Marketing is probably gleefully rubbing her hands together at all the outrage on this board because controversy = ratings and ratings = money.____What a shame.
I don't get it. I posted a comment several days ago — for the most part affirming other peoples' anti-Debbie observations — and it seemed to go through just fine. I couldn't understand what other posters were complaining about. Then, a couple of days later (a couple of days ago), I tried to post another comment — this time making the observation that the collegiality and respect exhibited on the latest episode of "Top Chef Masters" on Bravo could provide some constructive lessons for TNFNS contestants and producers as well. When I clicked on "Submit" I immediately got a rejection notice — no explanation, no nothing. What's going on? Is FN that eager to alienate its long-time viewers?
If Debbie wins this I have told my kids they can block FN on all our TV sets. They hope you're poor judgment continues.
AMEN
Agreed!
Agree with your opinion, but still think (hope) the judges will give her the boot. I will be very disappointed and surprised if they do not.
I'm with you! And still hope the FN will do the right thing.
I completely agree with you. This is the turning point for me with Food Network —and my negative reaction is much broader than just TNFNS! Kathleen
ESue - thanks for the suggestion. Question - can you tell me the name of a cooking program you like on PBS so that I can look for it? Thank you. Kathleen
Ok. was I to critical of Foodnetwork or to Susie? I didn't cuse (see I don't even know how to spell it ) Yes I was upset by Susie's vlog which was soooooooo condesending but I have read much worse. Yes I was critical of Debbie but I was not mean or snide about it ( some of the comments have made me feel bad for her and sorry that people are really that hateful) And yes I said you can lie to yourselfs but not to us but again it was mild compared to some so why was I deleted? Hit to close to the bone? Any doubt I had about Foodnetworks honesty and integrety was just DELETED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
I agree with you Kathy, the judges behavior is so contradictory to what they are saying that I can't believe their bosses don't call them on it!
I so agaree with you and that is what I was trying to get across with my question to Susie (she read mine). Debbie's "challege" was nothing but a gimmie and to have the judges act like it was difficult and that she did so much better than the others tells us a lot about the quality of the judging, IMO.
I thought of another one!
" KIMCHEAT " or " KIMCHEATER"
since she mentions KIMCHI in every show .
Like most everyone else I'm NOT AT ALL INTERESTED IN ANY SHOW FEATURING DEBBIE - I would love a show by Jeff - and maybe, could be OK with Melissa with some significant changes in her incessent talking and frenetic energy.
While I love to watch Food Network and DVR a lot of the shows to watch at day's end, I'm more than a little fed up with the over-kill of Rhachel Ray's multiple shows on - back2back2back 30 minutes meals, Tasty Travels, $40 a day, etc to the point I don't watch her at all, Sandra Lee's 2 shows are also non-favorites
as I've never tried 1 recipe even when I was watching! I WOULD like to have an Asian chef with good teaching techniques and easy recipes as it's a cuisine I'd like to try at home, just not with Debbie - she lost all creditability long ago!
OMG! People are getting really really into all of this! It makes me wonder why so many FN viewers are so very upset, and it occurs to me: which one of us has not had that first part-time job during high school or maybe that first big job after college, where we had a supervisor or manager that lied and took credit for every darn good idea and thing we did, and blamed the heck out of us if anything went wrong. Do you remember that frustrating feeling, getting blamed for all the bad and getting ignored and robbed of all the good? I think that maybe Debbie is the poster child for all those lying cheating coworkers that made us go home from working needing to kick the dog (don't worry, I didn't have a dog)…. but anyway…. psychologists may call this "catharsis" and it just may be what the doctor ordered, so keep on letting that steam off, it's good for you to not keep it all in.
By the way, I wouldn't watch a show by Debbie either, (even though I would enjoy learning a bit more about Korean cooking but as for Southern cooking, pleeeeease PD has that down pat! - Hah!) but I will darn well not cheat myself out of seeing some of my favorite FN shows, like sweet harmless great-recipe producing Paula, or yes, even lovey-dovey (gag, but glad for them) Neelys who have the best recipes I've ever tried, or funny and enlightening Bobby Flay, and so on - not even Debbie's cheating dishonesty that lays her competitors by the wayside or Susie's attempt to fix things by putting a slant to them….
I mean look at it from a marketing standpoint, even with the unfair challenges, Debbie does handle the camera well, and poor Michael just couldn't get past the camera, it does make some sense…. By the way, as a Mom of three, I would watch Melissa and I think she can improve her camera presence….
Just my 2¢…
Hope you are right!
Excellent reasoning and reply. Thank you.
LOL Sandra-thanks, I needed that! Agree-totally!
I don't think Debbie WON - since she is on a book signing tour.
(according to this site).
I agree Karen
agree completely-well said
from your blog to the judges votes I hope
I too hope Debbie does not make it. I feel she is not trustworthy. If she did win I would never watch her show.
Where's the magic???
There's no reason to watch anymore. Why don't you just pick people for the network, and forget the competition. I no longer think this is a fair fight. I can see your point, your job, your objectives,…what about the contestants, what about the viewers.
Dangle raw meat in front of a hungry dog and the meat will be devoured every time. Dangle the chance to lie in front of Debbie and she will do it every time. I may be wrong, but I think Bobby Flay has a good grasped of the situation, and Bob and Susie should follow his lead. Bob and Susie reveal their bias too much as to the contestant they are cheering for.
Regardless of what accusation is thrown at the Debbie-haters.. I believe the majority can definitely be construed as this: When we are pitched a product for sale, we want to know if what is being pitched is true, is it being advertised as truthfully as possible? Is the price just right? What can we expect from this product?
I believe that to be so in real life in many different situations: With Debbie - yes her product appears to be doing the trick for how she is describing it. However, when you are presented with what we are given - and yes, the fact that she hasnt been honest nor held herself accountable - I mean to be quite honest, she hasnt been honest with herself very well - do we want to rely on this type of show that doesnt deliver?
Mistakes are easy to correct when given the opportunity to do so, but when they become repetitive whether they are the same or a derivative - anyone has the right to question the validity, the accountability and the responsibility that we are looking for, when it is not there.
I agree..Debbie was favored and given a much easier task. Look at how the cost constantly called Melissa the wrong name. I am very disappointed myself in how Debbie has been allowed to lie.
Susie, I appreciate your smile and "encouragement" to the finalists. One thing I hate more than anything are the sour, grumpy, angry faces of the judges. I have seen Bobby, Alex G. and others look like they were angry while watching the contestants. Why? If this keeps up, I will be tempted to stop watching the Next Foodnetwork Star, Chopped, et cetera. It is wrong and difficult to watch. I appreciate the way you and Bob T. handle the contestants. I have never seen you with an angry face–you are able to portray your true feelings about a situation without showing anger or disgust.
I will NEVER watch Debbie if she has a show. She has serious integrity issues. I do like both Jeffrey and Melissa.
Hmmm…..after a great deal of thought and as a very, very long time viewer of FN I feel compelled to comment. I have never posted a comment before….but, have read all of the comments over the course of the past 4 weeks as well as having viewed the shows.__Debbie, in the last competition claims that her desire is to "bond and unite" people and teach them her Korean cuisine….she only mentions "kimshee".__Quite frankly, if I had any desire to prepare "kimshee"….I subscribe to many other web-sites….from which I could easily find a recipe for said item.__Her behaviour over the course of the past 4 weeks that I have been able to view has certainly not engendered either "bonding or uniting". She seems to have been a divisive personality that has displayed her expertise in either portraying herself as a "selfless" martyr…….or "oh, the capers?, they are in the dressing….."__She certainly must have a grandiose egotistical sense of self if she does not realize that both the judges as well as the viewers see her faux pas, a kind sugar coating of her deception, I might add.
I love this show but I am disheartened by the whole Debbie fiasco. I will never watch a show with her in it. And Susie - no need to talk to your viewers with sarcasm or a condescending tone. Not appreciated. I was looking forward to this vlog to see your responses…..again - not appreciated by this loyal viewer.
I haven't heard you say much of anything good about Jeffrey - look how many challenges he has won and if you have read his blog - wow….
You always just glow when Debbie speaks I mean lies….need to be a little less obvious next year.
In the Miami fiasco, debbie seemed confused about the word "selfless"… perhaps it is because she is "Korean" (not!) as she is always telling the audience… I think she really meant to say "selFISH!" And pardon me, but what ADULT says… "My bad" in the middle of an interview?? (Oh yeah, I forgot…. one caught in a lie!)
Really, FN..do you have to continue to torture us with lying Debbie for another week? I've never felt so compelled to have to comment in a public forum, but I'm just floored at the thought that someone who so clearly lacks character and integrity could stand to be hand chosen to potentially win such a huge opportunity. After reading all of the other disappointed FN fans, I thought it wasn't necessary to add to the clear disenchantment with the shows chosen path, but if there's any possibility we can influence this outcome, I'll do whatever it takes. I really could care less what the judges are seeing 'off screen', from what we've see on screen, we the audience cannot and will not connect with Debbie. I'm always willing to give second chances, but this is beyond forgiving. Her behavior stands for itself and should not be tolerated. Debbie could be the best chef in the world and you couldn't pay me enough to eat her food or watch her show. She's left my taste buds sour and my stomach nauseous….how is that for your marketability and camera presence. I like Jeffrey, but my vote is for Melissa. She's so genuine and likable. She's obviously talented and her story is inspiring, now that's star quality worthy of a life changing opportunity.
What book? I want to be sure not to get it!
Hi Susie! Actions speak louder than words. Yes; even if the one word is "No". I skiped Next FNStar this week as well as everything else on FN. I did check your answer to questions this week mostely because I need a good laugh! They question is : Why does FN Network put on camera ready above honesty and Intergrity???????
Gosh, I thought I was the only one who did not care for Debbie. I will not watch her if she wins. That is my choice. We need to remember we have a choice in viewing. There are lots of shows on the Food Network that I do not particularly like, I just do not watch them. If Debbie wins, I'll simply watch something else.
I find Debbie smug and unlikeable. Melissa is open, honest and is working hard. I go back and forth about Jeffrey. Initially I liked him, but I do find him to be very bland. That said, I ate at Red Lobster last night, the first time in over 15 years, just to try his dish and I must say it was delicious.
All in all, this show is fun and I enjoy it. If I do not agree with the final selection, ultimately it remains in my hands because I do not have to watch the host they select if I do not want to.
There is a book out there called 'Romantic Liars authored by Debbie Lee
This Debbie Lee teaches at Wash State U. heheh
http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Romantic-Liars/D...
There is a book out there called 'Romantic Liars: Obscure Women Who Became Impostors and Challenged an Empire' authored by Debbie Lee
This Debbie Lee teaches at Wash State U. heheh
There is a book out there called 'Romantic Liars: Obscure Women Who Became Impostors and Challenged an Empire' authored by Debbie Lee
This Debbie Lee teaches at Wash State U. heheh
http://search.barnesandnoble.com/Romantic-Liars/D...
I think perhaps the problem is that alot of the viewing audience has a different meaning of integrity than do the judges. It really is sad to see so many negative things being written about Debbie but the truth is, from the very start, the judges said intregrity was a must for a foodnetwork star. Had that not been made a point, perhaps there wouldn't have been such a firestorm. I do believe sending Jamika home was a good choice. I am the first to say that some of the challenges given to these contestants are tough. Even Bobby F. would probably mess up on these. Little time, faulty equip etc. However, you have to keep a positive attitude and Jamika just didn't . Things don't always go right in the real world and I wouldn't want to watch her "zone" face. Her getting snippy with Bob was uncalled for. Anyway, I think Melissa or Jeff would have a great show. I think Melissa can overcome her hyperness. Nervousness is understandable and she seems to be able to control it now. Her food sounds awesome.
Sandra,
I completely agree with you! Susie comes across as condescending and I do not appreciate it. I can take my dollars elsewhere, thank you very much.
And as far as the laughable challenge, the FN had to make sure that the liar at least won one challenge. This is the first and only challege that she has won and she had the easiest task.
Al,
I love you! Will you marry me? Just kidding. Your post was very well said. It's almost like TPTB at FN think their viewers are stupid sheep that will follow them anywhere and believe anything they say.
I'm not so sure that the FN's definition of integrity is the same as the rest of us.
You evently haven't been watching since day "1"
Why am I feeling so manipulated? Debbie CANNOT be the winner. If she is well then ok I hope she is on the same time as Man vs. Food cuz I won't be anywhere near the Food Network at that time. Actually. If anything else is on at the same time I wouldn't be watching the Food Network.
Well lets see I tried posting earlier and no luck.
I hope the preview of Bobby saying get rid of her in the judgeing session was in reference to Debbie and not Melissa,
If she were I wouldn't watch her show. INTEGRITY MATTERS TO ME!!!!
ok. so can we vote off susie and debbie? dont think so. our opinions DONT MATTER.
I think the biggest Question I see people asking is that WHY keep Debbie when it is so obviouse that NO ONE will watch her is she recieves her own show. usless the food network get a good deal of money for writing of a failed show. BUt that would be cruel to Debbie, NO I do not like her, the whole we may be biest against her True or not she did have it the easiest. and Hello we are campaining against her.
If the powers that be look at the fan vote, on who the viewers want voted off, they would see the majority want to get rid of Debbie.
I will not watch her show if she is the winner. I, along with many others do not approve of her lying ways.
I wonder if our opinion counts.
Hi Susie,
This is something that has been bothering me for quite sometime now. These last few challenges, both you and Bobby have brought up some valid points in regards to Debbie's honesty. (not sure what the appropriate would be here) We as viewers see her in a negative light. I'm just wondering how well she would come off on the FN level in a negative level to start with. Afterall, it has been stressed that it's all about marketing, if the viewers can't trust her then how can the network trust her? In otherwords, if she were to receive her own, how would you know that she wouldn't treat the network as she has done her fellow contestants as well as us viewers? Right now, we are feeling rather cheated being as she has not been let go yet.
The real issue here is that neither Susie or Bob have every stood before a camera and done any cooking. Bobby F. has at least some idea of what a new cook goes through. I have watched this show for the third year now and I too, am sick of the way Susie comes across as a judge. Off with Debbie and on with Melissa she has the presence to develope into a wonderful show host.
If your answers are going to be reduced to smugness, sarcasm, or simple "yes" "no" answers, save it. True, there is an intense dislike of Debbie among the posters here. However, that does NOT make losing a fork more difficult than an obnoxious host or meddlesome equipment. You asked us to give you guys some credit, some trust. How 'bout a little respect on our end? Remember, we're the viewers, and more importantly, THE CONSUMERS.
I must comment again after hearing Susie's replies to all the comments regarding Debbie. Beside Mr Irvine and possibly now Debbie I wonder if we should question the integrity of other Food Network stars. How many things do we bot know about the other people we watch or the ones we choose not to watch. I never watch Guy he is worse than Emeril ever was; loud and obnoxious. I really miss the Hearty boys (my favs of all the previous winners) Maybe integrity is not important to the judges and I guess we should question them more to get a real feel for thier definition of integrity and honesty. I keep hoping that good will win out but I am beginning to wonder if it will. Melissa drives me nuts but I would watch her show and I think Jeffery is by far the best choice.
I would love to hear an apologyfrom Susie for calling most of the viewers biased but I am not holding my breath.
Have you read these comments? You talk about your contestants having a slow learning curve!
Well said!
Hi Richard: and continuing to watch even though you hate her is why she's still on: I stopped watching after the fisrst episode when she wasn't called by the judges on sabotaging the shopping (I noticed none of *her* ingredients got left behind) and not stepping up about the dessert. I realise that these are taped far in advance, but If people simply refuse to watch the final if Debbie is in it, someone in the organisation will have something to say about it
Still can't believe that you all have not gotten rid of Debbie.I can't watch a show with someone that continues to be unthruthful and did not use all the ingredients that Bobby gave her. Where is the interigity ?If she wins I really don't know what to think about you judges.
You make a good point Delinda. I wonder if the bosses HAVE called them on it? This show was taped 6 month ago. It's not like they can retape. Well, they could but that won't happen. But the bosses could be saying, "What were you thinking?" I can understand keeping a contestant on for ratings up to a point, but this has gone on too long. If she doesn't go Sunday night and TPTB are keeping her yet another week for ratings, I believe they will be shooting themselves in the foot. The viewers are not stupid. We value integrity and are not getting it from these judges. Bobby Flay has dropped a few notches in my book.
I know I'm too late with my sincerest hope that DTK is gone (the dye has been cast). However, it has recently occured to me that if Debbie Lee IS the winner, then Food Network REALLY screwed up by broadcasting all her lies and back stabbing and mean-spirited manipulations for all of us to see. Surely, FN would NOT want us to see that side of their newest attraction (sounds like a carnival ride). SOOOO my faith has been renewed!!!!!! Debbie CAN'T be the winner….. YA BA DUB BA DOOOO!!!!
I also skipped the Food Netwrk this week. Having just gotten Fios Tv, there are so very many cooking shows and other things to watch, I actually did not miss all the chatter from so many. So if Debbie continues, I will for the most part leave. There is no way for me to watch her. I am way to old, at 80, to watch and listen to her type of person.
Perhaps the problem is that the Next Food Network Star does not have a solid POV: showmanship vs. food.
I've viewed a few episodes of Chopped, and any deviation from the rules means the chef is chopped. For each challenge, all the chefs have the same ingredients, and not using all of them will Chop the chef. In one episode, a chef continued to plate his food several seconds after the time was up — he was Chopped even though all his courses were considered successes.
However, the NFNS does not present a level playing field for the contestants and puts them in situations that seem far removed from the rigors & challenges of a TV show. Yes, food matters — we have to trust that the chef is presenting us with successful recipes. Yes, personality & style counts — this is how loyal viewers & advertisers are attracted. Yet the NFNS seems to be focusing on all the negatives and drama rather than locating & cultivating the next Star. Viewers are certainly reacting to this. You may think this is positive for ratings, but it is short sighted & ultimately defeating.
If Debbie — who shouldn't be there — makes it through, no way in you know what will I watch the finale OR ever watch the contest again. Already, FN is no longer my go-to channel like it was before as I veg out in the evenings. Instead, I'm finding comfort elsewhere. Just don't feel the same…when you can see the sausages being made (cutting programs to create someone to dislike and then keeping the person), the kimchee really smells up the room.
Debbbie is too consumed with trying to win to worry about ethics and it really comes across badly on TV. She needs to explain and redeem herself to be a successful FN star.
Personally, Melissa bores me and she's just too bubbly for my taste. I really hope Jeffrey wins.
But I'm sorry you eliminated Michael and Jamica, both were entertaining and seemed to make delicious food.
If I dont like the host… I dont watch. It is really just that simple.
FN should be paying attention to the weekly voting. Debbie was "voted off" by the public weeks ago.
I don't get how the challenges the contestants have been faced with have anything to do with becoming the Next Food Network Star and the host of a cooking show with a specific culinary point of view.
None of the current chefs/non-chef good cooks on the network have to shop in 15 minutes - 1/2 hour, in a strange city, in a strange market, to get ingredients for recipes they have to make up on-the-fly, with not enough money to pay for what they want to use. They all have well paid back stage crew members and food artists to do all the leg work for them (money no object). They don't have to do anything under any other time constraint than the length of said show. They get weeks to plan the programming content and they get the input of test kitchen chefs, professional writers, make-up artists, producers, directors, etc., etc., etc. All they have to do is attend the planning meetings, come up with a few good ideas and have a marketable television appearance and like-ability to draw repeat viewers. Nothing TNFNS have to go through even pertains to the job they are competing for. It's like watching a bunch of keystone cops try to perform heart surgery going down the class 5 rapids on some river in Colorado.
I agree with all of you. I had small children and when I was younger my kitchen was under-stocked, so I have had to come up with some improvisions a lot harder then stirring with my fingers or finding a fork replacement. The others faced out side interference. I am sure that Jeffery and Melissa could have been just as creative and calm over missing silverware
took me a while to warm up to Guy, was kind of loud, but got use to him and like him now
I think Debbie did have the easiest rigged demo. The other demos
were bordering on obnoxious. As for Jamica, she was just being
honest to the critics and did not hold a candle to the sarcastic
looks I have seen from the judges and chefs. Case in point,
the sneak peak at the Julia challenge. I think you should bring Jamica back.
melissa should win she is such a positive women and she can cook i think she can certainly tame her nervousness as u can c from watching her in ep.7 she can really be a help to people needing easy and kid friendly meals i think she can be a very organized and come up with a great show
after seeing jamika get so upset in ep.7 i was so surprised i never realized how upset she could get under pressure
What do u think
at the begin. of the season some people sounded more innocent then they really were do u think jeff. is a fake like debbie too i hope not
ii want to think the same but debbie and jeff sound sneaky to me
i think micheal could have had a really good show if he worked on his camera presence
he would prob. be a very entertaining fn star
It comes down to who is most watchable among the three. With Melissa she smiles but she seems almost as empty inside as Katie was on camera. Her performance is lacking in consistency. Jeffrey is charming, but he may be too vanilla to watch, and we still know nothing more about him other than he has a kid. I think Debbie does default in to deny deny deny mode when she's caught with he hand in the cookie jar, and that may be a problem when somebody is responsible for their own show. If things go wrong, can she take accountability? It may be that I am rooting for Debbie because I would like a Food Network to show greater diversity and she has a great onscreen presence.
I agree-I would have watched both of them!
I sure hope you are right-tonight may tell!
Kathleen-do not have any suggestions yet-will let you know if I find shows I like. In fact-will ask the viewers-watch for suggestions.
Debbie is an insult to all the hard working people on the show. She is a liar,dishonest and a back stabber.Jamika gets sent home for showing honest emotion and speaking honestly yet again you judges sugarcoat Debbies lies and get rid of the best contestant of the bunch.Michael Symon is a twit but at least he was honest about Jamicka being the best of all the contestants and he had tunnel vision as well and sent her home.Foodnetworks loss because the girl is going places and you all are stuck with the liar of the year. Hey pinocchio ,we found your sister and her name is Debbie.Trust this, if Debbie wins her show will never be viewed in this household. Judges stop insulting integrity and honesty unless you all can show it yourselves by giving Debbie the boot. What does your boss say about this?
Viewers, several of you have mentioned alternative cooking shows that you like on other networks. I am familiar with Bravo's Top Chef, what else do you recommend? Inquiring minds want to know…Thanks! Sue
another try,last comment was deleted. okay, I asked my son who is an amateur chef. He has studied at Cordon Bleu in D.C. and Escoffier in Paris, France to watch the latest episode - the TV challenge. He called after the show and stated that he ROFL. How could Debbie's challenge be such? no one poured hot sauce in her ingredients, no boom mike or producer {/} poked in. And — she forgot and ingredient and Lied about it.
Although, great camera pretense [deliberate sp.] was obvious. Debbie will cry tears all the way to bank. Please do not compare Debbie to Margaret Cho. Cho is an unpretentious pro and great.
lisapen-please, do not turn this into a racial slur. We do not like Debbie's behavior. Her roots have nothing to do with it, nor should it. Please be careful. You have a point that will be lost if you turn it into hate mail.
LOL-thanks, I needed that!
I so agree with you-fingers crossed they return our faith in them tonight!
Well written-I agree.
Well put-I agree
Marcia-worse in my thinking, they manipulated the stars, contestants and the viewers, showing no repect for anyone for the sake of hyping the show. I hope I am right and they will get rid of her tonight. If not…I will losoe serious respect for the FN.
I agree with you completly!
I agree with you and hope this is the outcome.
Well written-I agree
You are correct, but remember, you have questionable power in your vote with the FN, but you have absolute power with your choice of viewing, and your choice of purchasing products, services and goods from the FN and their sponsors. Boycotting the FN and their sponsors and letting them know why is powerful. If Debbie gets a show…Let the FN and their sponsors know that you disapprove.
You feel manipulated because you have been. The FN stars, contestants and viewers all have been. I am with you on that! I still hold out hope that they will make it right tonight. Fingers ctrossed-let's see…
Could not agree with you more-fingers crossed…
I WISH!
Boy, do I agree!
AMEN!
Faye-I agree with you
Very well written-I agree
Susan-Very well summed up and I agree with you! Sue
You ask for our opinion yet you do not want to listen to what we have to say and then you'll down our opinions. we are not stupid and we now what we want to watch I will not watch her and i will find other food shows whether it be on food net work or other networks. You'll kick people for lying and blaming other people for their mistakes yet she it on last weeks show and told Bob he was wrong in so many words and you did not care about that and the week before she did not hope out and did not do her job to help out and make sure things in the kitchen like she was supposed to do. You'll cannot face the fast that she is dishonest and only out for her self. yet you still want to down us That is not right makes me wonder if watching food network is worth watching since you do not really care about our opinion.
While I think it is too late to bring Jamika back this season, I would watch her on another show in a minute. Actually, Michael too….
Susie, did you eat any of the crap food the Eden Roc serves ? If you did and thought it was good enough to stay at that Hotel for 3 epispodes, I can see why you can't be honest about the foods served by the contestants. By the way what is your favorite food?
smug in a jug.
You know, I have mixed emotions on this one…first of all, previously she did freeze up… but having seen the FN since they started, I saw different treatment for potential stars. They used to work with people's strengths, play down they weaknesses, nurture them, give them positive feedback and show them in their own genres. Now, unrealistic challenges and how fast can we get thm before the camera with minimal effort and it shows. None of their stars, including Bobby Flay, (my personal favorite), was that smooth at the beginning. But given time and help…an FN star.
Doubt it. Think he needs work but would be my pick today. We'll see after tonight's episode. Debbie is a little tpp hyper for me and I thinkk many females have her point of view covered.
We should say goodbye to Debbie. People watch the FN for two main reasons - the personalities and to learn new cooking skills, techniques and dishes. Integrity is a huge factor that gravitates people to personalities. It is therefore imperative for the FN to consider the public's voice. We need someone that represents what we want to watch… That is none other than Jeffrey now that Jamika is gone
It will count when nobody watches her show.
i am afraid I agree with you. I haven written the FN on several occasions about theit over exposure of certain stars-mostly female. While I loved them to begin with, I am sick to death of Paula, Ina, Giada and Rachel. I especially hate that they have transformed a down-home lovely and charming Paula into an over made up crude, lewd and rude hostess of Paula's party. Progress? I think not.
So, let me get this straight, Debbie "aced" the rigged challenge? Debbie only had to deal with a few missing utensils and a substitution, whereas the other contestants had to deal with far greater/obnoxious distractions that disturbed the rhythm of their presentations. Also, Debbie did not try to misrepresent using all of the ingredients during another challenge, i.e., the "Capers Incident?" Come on, really Susie?!?!
There are legitimate questions being raised as well as reasons stated by many of the posted comments by bloggers, who are expressing their concern over integrity being jettisoned for ratings. I have to say for this week's blog posting, Susie, your POV/camera presence was lacking and downright condescending.
I just want to say what everyone else is saying. Get rid of Debbie. She can't be trusted. Melissa is clearly the one who should win.
well written-I agree!
the question of the season…
well said-but remember, you also vote with your purchases. If she does get a show, (which I really hope does not happen) boycott the show, the FN network and it's sponsors. And let them know why. We have listed the names and addresses of the CEOs of the FN and their parent company as well as a list of their sponsors. Your voice does count…but only if you use it!
Ditto with everyone - Debbie needs to go. I don't trust her. Melissa impresses me with her knowledge base for a home cook. She can get wound up easily, but that can be handled in a positive way. I like Jeffrey too, but he is a little vanilla. My vote goes to Melissa. She makes me feel less intimidated knowing her background is not a professional chef. I can relate to that.
I agree! Here's hping tonight is the night!
Agreed-Hope tonight is the night thry prove it!
HERE'S HOPING TONIGHT THEY PROVE IT!
text right here
Well, finally Sunday evening is here. As I just told Bob, I wish you good luck Susie. This is either going to be real pretty or real ugly.
The grill is fired up and I feel an adult beverage is in order. Considering opening a fine bottle of wine for the occasion, but might just go straight fot the scotch on the rocks to prepare for the worse.
T minus 2hours three mins,,, and all systems are go .
Susie,
Enough said about Debbie, I think we're all pretty clear. My vote is for Melissa because I think she has a lot to offer everyday lives. She has shown wonderful progress each week and tries hard to take to heart all the criticism offered and make steady improvements. My only worry is that, as a stay at home mom, the life of a Food Network star would take it's toll on her and her family (as in Amy last year). That said, I also think I'd watch Jeffery, but I prefer Melissa.
I appreciate your comments on the videos and I sincerely hope that you do put integrity first in the end.
You people that are commenting on the Debbie issue are just crazy yourselves. How can you base opinions on people when al you see is the editied versions of the shows. They edit that way to get you sitrred up so that you will blog on this site. They are getting what they want. These shows are already taped and in the can. They already have a winner. I hope that it is Debbie. I like her and the only people that are blogging on this site are Debbie haters. Like I said I hope Debbie wins and if not Melissa. Jeffery is soooooo boring. Can not relate to him. But if he wins it doesn't mean that I am going to boycott the network. You people that say you will not watch will be the first ones to tune in.
KimH said>"t comes down to who is most watchable among the three. With Melissa she smiles but she seems almost as empty inside as Katie was on camera."
———————-
Empty? I think you should read her bio…that woman is one smart lady. I HATE blondes, but I have to admit that Melissa has more than what it takes to succeed at darn near anything. And I would give a show she had a very decent and long look.
Susie i love you. With what is going on around us, it is so nice to watch you. Yes, show Debbie the door. NOW!!!
I am hopeful Jeffrey is the winner. I'll be crestfallen if Debbie wins. I have loved FN and many of its hosts. Debbie will definitely tarnish the station and I will be gravely disappointed that FN would not factor in the large number of fans who have expressed a dislike of her. I'd feel that their business plan is of greater importance than we. If our voices are not important, then why go through the charade. Just pick someone and we'll be stuck with that person or we'll move on to Bravo.
Liar, liar pants on fire! and crocodile tears to boot!! there is too much at stake for the food network to allow the farce to continue. besides, if i recall, didn't the judges eliminate someone from the last series, who was also disingenuous. GET RID OF DEBBIE NOW!!
I agree, enough Rachel Ray already. An Asian chef would
be like a breath of fresh air
I agree, enough Rachel Ray already. An Asian chef would
be like a breath of fresh air
Personally, I would love to curl up on my couch with a nice cup of coffee and watch Debbie. Jeffrey would put me to sleep, and Melissa would give me anxiety.
In the beginning, I saw different treatment for potential stars. They used to work with people's strengths, play down their weaknesses, nurture them, give them positive feedback and show them in their own genres. Now, they have unrealistic challenges and it feels like the FN attitdue is: how fast can we get them before the camera with minimal effort . And it shows. None of their stars, including Bobby Flay, (my personal favorite), was that smooth at the beginning. But given time and help, became FN stars. I miss Jamica and Michael. Viva la difference!
I agree!
Could not agree with you more-well said!
To all the regular posters on this blog and those not so regular posters:
If Debbie does not go home tonight, do not give FN the satisfaction of you posting your outrage. JUST DO NOT POST ANYTHING! Show your outrage by your SILENCE! Actions speak louder than words. Do not give FN the ability to say they had so many # of posts after the episode to justify keeping the liar. JUST DON'T POST! BE SILENT!
Off we go ladies and gentlemen……will it be another "Capergate" or another watershed? Time will tell….
As always…..controversy creates veiwership and isn't that a bit of a sad commentary?
May the best "man" win……ultimately, it certainly won't be the FN.
I really like watching Jeff, his easy going way makes it easy to understand. I am looking forward to learning more from him.
Melissa is also very interesting, I am not a mom but I am sure she has a lot of helpful hits.
I would like to see both Jeff and Melissa have a show.
I have learned a lot from FN, Rachel Ray has really taught me a lot in the short time I have been watching. Thanks for a lot of good shows.
How could my post be deleted by the administrater the second I pushed submit?
I saw an article in the foodnetwork magazine about Debbie opening a hotdog place in LA. I do not think she wins.
If you do not like the winner than do not watch their show. Ratings will tell the FN. Both Jeffrey and Melissa are good. But I do not find Jeffrey charming enough. Debbie's dishonesty and performance in the team challenge have soured me.
Amen…….
Finally Debbie is gone!! I will be happy with either Melissa or Jeffrey winning. I would not have said that a few weeks ago, but Melissa is winning me over. I still like Jeffery more but would watch either one of them
I have just watched the show with the 3 finalists. THANK YOU SO MUCH for eliminating Debbie. She definitely had to go. I think Melissa should be the winner.
THANK YOU,THANK YOU!!!!!
Boooorrrriinnnngggg! That's right boring! Jeffery and Melissa are boring. To give either of them a show is a plain waste of time and money.
Love Melissa. I would enjoy watching her and her cook her recipes. She has calmed the energy down. Even with her high energy I feel like I can relate to her and would love to hear more from her. I am looking forward to learn all that she has to show us about great home cooking. With the slowdown in the community, she is a breath of fresh air. I can see her doing a cookbook, cookware, and recipes we can all cook after a hard day of work.
AMEN!!, AMEN!!, AMEN!!, AMEN. Finally!!!!!!!!! Would love to see a
show with Melissa. Feel better knowing new show will not include
Debbie Lee. Anyone but her. Can not wait for next week.
jUst watched the episode tonight Sun. 7/26 and so so relieved to see the outcome. I am amazed that it all had to come to the last three that included Debbie. Jamika should have been in that three but oh well. Debbie i gone and I flipped back and forth because I really wan't planning on watching the next FNS tonight and was shocked that you all made the decision that you made. Debbie wa not even pleasant to look at. By the way, Sunday all day my tv is on FN channel all day til the end. My fav's are the Neely's, Anne Burel, Ina Garten, Sandra Lee, Guy Fieri anytime, and that is about it. I have no use for the rest. Good job tonight for hearing our pleas.
Hooray, she is finally gone!!! You know who I'm talking about, the show aired here in So. Florida 9-10PM EDT. Now it's 10:45PM, but perhaps folks on the west coast have not yet seen this episode.
Susie, I'm an accomplished cook and pretty good baker. I don't watch the FN to learn how to cook, I watch for the entertainment. Over the years I have picked up some valuable tips from the different Chefs. I've tried different foods because of the ease with which the foods were presented. I'm going back to the early days of Sarah Molton and Molto Mario, they entertained me and introduced me to new foods. Eventually my local supermarkets started carrying many of the "new" foods. 15 years ago who even heard of fennel, now it's everywhere.
At this point I almost don't care who wins next week, however, I think Jeffery will entertain me more than Melissa. Both would be an excellent addtion to the FN.
It's been a fun 2 months, you folks really got me fired up week after week, but finally, "she's gone", hooray.
WTG Susie ~~ we hung in therre with ya and you guys FINALLY made the correct call! Cant wait until next Sunday for the finals
I am only going to say thank you. I don't know if it hasnt been shown everywhere. But thank you.
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Happy Happy Day! The cheers of joy were rising from our house tonight. We will be thrilled if either of the last two finalists wins. Great job FN!
Were down to two, and the right two from my chair, now who would you like to see there( they both can cook for sure) but all in all the one that shine the most is Mellisa, Jef is just to stiff, Mellisa has a smile on her face all the time, and a charm that just pull you in. My pick for the next foodnet work star is Mellisa hands down….
THANK the Gods that DTK is GONE. Either Jeffrey or Melissa would be great as the winner, and hopefully the 2nd place finisher will get a show anyway. But, please no more Debbie.
I was really expecting my Jeffrey to be kicked off this week because of his risotto dish, and was prepared to be voting for Melissa next week, when to my surprise, they voted Debbie off! I was shocked and happy, as I am sure most of the voters are on here. It will be a good competition next week, and if he doesn't win, well, at least he has shown class with every disappointment that he has had, and I know he will go far in whatever career he choses.
I am glad that my Jeffery survived this week, and know it will be a good challenge next week between him and Melissa. Even if he doesn't win, he has shown class with every disappointment that he has had, and I know that he will do well in whatever future endeavors he has.
Congratulations to Melissa and Jeffery. I hope Jeffery wins it, but I know he will handle it with class as he has handled all his disappointments. They both deserve to have made it to the end, and either one of them will make a good FN host. Good luck to both of them. The ending to this weeks challenge should make everybody happy!
I thought I was the only one who thought Debbie was a phony. Even her camera "presence" had a bit of Stepford Wives feel to it. I can't tell whether my opinion was influenced by her lying or what, but the longer she was on, the less I trusted or liked her. Just the opposite with Melissa … the more she's on and grows into herself the more interested I am in her POV. Jeffrey is so slick and confident … but Melissa might be the one to really connect. Right choice tonight, tho!
Jefferey seems to be all southwestern cusine. I would much rather to a housewife make a meal for friends and family. She can be taught how to slow down, but I don't think you can show Jefferey's versitally like Melissa can. She seems to be an incredibles chef and I would like to learn from her.
Who are you talking to? One of my bosses once said "it's not the problem you deal with, it's how you handle it." Debbie is *horrific* at handling problems
.
I'd never want to work with her. Ever. Would you?
If you think Debbie can be part of your money-making family then you are clearly mistaken. She has proved over and over that she can not work with anyone nor herself for that matter.
My point, in case you missed it, was that life is full of challenges and surprises. It's how one handles them that matters in the end. And her end in this competition is a welcome sight to my weary eyes.
Shame on you. Debbie would have added something much needed in regards to variety in good food to the food network.
I really wanted Jamika to win, but since she was eliminated last week. I want Jeff to be the winner. He has much experience. Melissa is the underdog here, she is capable to cook so well, but her dramatic stories and the constant mention of her kids make me uncomfortable to watch her and Debbie spent the entire show saying "I'm Korean" well she is a Korean descent but she is not Korean, she is American. I bet she doesn't speak a word of Korean and she lied many times during the show.
Finalleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. Finally we can get past this Debbie fiasco, and good luck to both Jeffery and Melissa.
you must have mentioned the old liar in their history - I got the same result!
Guess that they are overly sensitive about the whole issue - but then they should have gotten rid of the "truth bender" a long time ago - now I won't be watching. I may give them a second chance - but not until I have lost the anger that goes with them keeping Debbie and putting a filter up on "what's his name"
you finally got it right but then I thought after last weeks post how many weeks was this taped in advance and was any of our comments even read before the final show. Happy to see the two that are finalists. That would be a good question maybe How far in advance are the programs taped before we see them?
mrskoala
I don"t like that this year's show caused us to question not only the integrity of the contestant but also that of the judges and the network. I'm sure there are things in the lives of the current "stars" that might not look good on TV but we didn't have to see it. Please don't give us a "villian" next year. Show the contestant in realistic challlenges. I get no pleasure watching someone's dream fall apart trying to accomplish a task that has no bearing on what they may encounter on the job.
I cannot believe Jeffrey wasn't eliminated. He is very full of himself and I cannot imagine watching a show with him as host. He's also very quick to throw his competitors under the bus. He walked all over Jameka in the Rachel Ray episode; it came off to me as intentional. He blamed everyone else for the lack of food from the "kitchen" in the Miami outdoor party episode, he was in charge and chose to Host the event. He made a horrible "greatest dinner ever" tonight. $371 for 20 guests??? who spends that, especially when you know you are serving dinner to chefs. Less than $20 per person for a 3 course dinner. I just find him unwatchable.
finally Debbie was on the choping block and got boot. About time and it took to much time in my opinion. susie says that debbie was the most poised in the last episode's mini challenge. What I would like to see if she had the same difficulties as the other three would debbie be as poised, i think not. and we will never know but it is also my opinion that had the other three had the same challenge that debbie had they would have aced it also in any event. debbie is gone and good riddence. of the remaining two, either one woiuld do great with thier own show.
First comment - I miss being able to vote for the next star at the end. At the end of the day, who knows who we want to watch except us?
Second comment - I'm curious as to what would have happened if you had put Debbie straight on the air. I get the feeling we would have liked her quite fine.
The danger for these contestants is that the hidden camera catches unguarded moments, yet they can be edited in or out. I'm not saying that integrity doesn't count at the network (I remember Robert Irvine), but that adding the contest adds a unique "screening" element. You do have to wonder how some mainstream Food Network stars would have fared in this format.
Which leads me to my 3rd comment - I understand why Debbie was around for as long as she was. I think she has tremendous charisma on camera and her food chops were respectable. I think she did have lapses in judgement, but the capers thing wasn't one of them (I honestly think she forgot about getting them). Unfortunately, after the previous week, her credibility among the audience was set to zero.
I understand why a few team challenges are important, but so often they seem set up to torpedo contestants, not to let them shine. The "winner" is the one who suffers the least damage. Not very inspiring.
Susie, I think you are wonderful. I generally agree with your comments. I think you got it right this week by getting rid of Debbie. She had the talent and screen presence, but not the integrity to host a show. I hope with every fiber of my being that Melissa wins. She would be like a breath of fresh air on the Food Network. Jeffrey is likable but inconsistent.
Thank you Fn for getting rid of the after all Im korean Now just pick Melissa I dont care for Jeffery and would not watch him along with some others that I know. And Debbie did have easier challenga I wonder why that was. Was she the numser pick of the bunch Anyway Thank God she is gone Thank you also I would like to see Jamika back but would settle for Mellissa. And again I dont think I would watch Jeffery at all
I miss Jamica!!!!!!
Thanks Guys!!!!! Now you are on the right track with finalist. I just wish Jamekia could have lasted just a little longer.
Diane
Thank you so much for last nights decision to remove Debbie. The girl with no honesty or integrity!!!!!
So glad Debbie is gone! Would hurt her to take classes to better herself in how to talk to people. Also, I have a question. Why does everything have to have hot sauce, hot peppers, or spices in them! There are a lot of people that can't have foods with them because of health reasons?
I hope Melissa wins even though I like Jeffrey too! Hard choice!
I'm certainly glad Debbie was FINALLY sent home, however, I certainly do hope that FN does not deem her "talented" enough get her own show. Adam getting his own shot was a good thing because he was a good guy, funny, sincere, in others words-real.
Debbie, not so much, no matter if she won FNS or FN "gives" her her own show I would not watch it, why? Because you cannot repackage her enough to negate the damage she did to herself on FNS.
To Joi: So I take it you don't like Rachel Ray either? Rachel does a lot of talking on her show, maybe you like Ina (Barefoot Contessa) she is as dull and boring as they come and how on earth she landed a show is beyond me! Jeffrey is good, but has an arrogant air about him. But, I could watch him or Melissa…Melissa is so down to earth and doesn't go on and on and on about her life, but engages he audience just enough.
Not disappointed to see Debbie leave. She probably is a pretty good cook, but I think personality matters more than that(given what seems to be Food Network’s goals.) Melissa might have a chance at actually being a “star” rather than just getting a show.
Hey, Susie! I just had a question about Jeffrey. LIke Bobby, I've noticed that Jeffrey's performance is consistently "okay". But, to me, it's never really been intriguing or fun, just "okay". So, now for the question: Is Bobby the only one on the panel who sees that, as a rule, Jeffrey has a certain "okay"-ness or do you and Bob have the privelege of seeing a better side to Jeffrey because I would genuinely like to like him. Thanks!
I agree with you about Jeff and I am pleased with the last two contenders….my friend and I are having a war tho about who should win! I like some of the food that Melissa cooks but her personality is what we will have to listen to constantly with her own show and I don't think I could stand it! He is more subdued and has a cutesy personality….and is a great chef! Anyone agree?? Melissa is just to fake confident!
The next decision will be a tough one. Jeffrey has a good personality and can be interesting to wath. He has much to offer TFN. Melissa is a homemaker and also (now that she is slower speaking) also a great personality and has some good skills and ideas. How about a show featuring both of them? Or maybe give them both a show?
Thank you for getting rid of Debbie - how nice that you finally listen to your viewers. Melissa should be your pick to win. Now if you just get rid of the Neeley's, life would be sweet.
I couldn't stand Debbie, and was shocked and thrilled to see her go last night. Finally!!!!! But for the 12 Debbie fans out there, don't despair - Food Network will give her a show anyway, just like that Adam Whatzit from last year with "Will Work for Food". There will be a "Seoul to Soul" show coming soon, you can bank on that. And she'll have all 12 viewers. No one likes her, she's obnoxious. I don't know how she's supposed to be so "camera ready". The viewers don't like her, so it's a total waste. She can lie with a straight face and cook some odd combos. What an asset!
Enter text right here! I HAVE NOT MISS A SHOW. HAVE ELIMINATED THE ONES THAT DO NOT APPEAL TO ME. OUT OF JEFFREY AND MELISSA MY VOTE IS FOR JEFFREY, HE HAS A CHARISMA THAT MAKES ME WATCH THE SHOW. LAST NIGHT MELISSA TRIED TO GET THE JUDGES ATTENTION WITH HER STORY (THERE WAS A COUPLE OF THEM CRYING), I DID NOT LIKE WHAT SHE TRIED TO DO. YOU WIN BECAUSE OF TALENT, AND HOW YOU ATRACT THE VIEWERS, THAT IS VERY IMPORTANT. TO ME JEFFREY IS THE PERFECT CANDIDATE TO BE NEXT GREAT START OF THE FOOD NETWORK. I'LL BE GOING TO RED LOBSTER TO TRY HIS DISH . GOOD LUCK IN YOUR SELECTION, ALL OF YOU JUDGES ARE SUPERB.
Joi I agree with you. I was not interested in a Korean show. I can handle either Jeff or Melissa. I have had some training in Chinese cooking and would also like to see a true Asian show.
Diane -
I agree!
At 21 I married, moved to NYC and discovered Julia Child on PBS. She gave me the courage to try new things, showed technique and not be overly concerned. So years later I am a fan of Food Network and I'm waiting for the J/J movie to open. I believe that Melissa brings that same quality: she has technique, variety (I want her pastry recipes) and lots of experiences that home cooks understand. There are lots of levels of sophistication of home cooks. I can see her relating well to audiences. The structure of this elimination is very aggressive - more boot camp-like rather than showing what these contestants (whose videos charmed you judges enough to bring to us) can do. I question whether some of your current stars could have survived this boot camp environment. The trickery feels more like the wrestling show biz than a serious attempt to find a competent, likeable next FN show host. Are you purposely dumbing everything down, or am I just getting old? The final two are good ones - I too was troubled with Debbie's difficulty with the truth and your repeated acceptance of it - just like the many sports stars/celebrities who refuse to play by the rules and get away with the mountains of money/fame. Melissa feels real, and I think would get a following. I think you can build a brand around her and she will represent your Network brilliantly.
I'm a Jeffrey fan, Melissa is good she seems sweet but DANG enough about the stay at home mommy! I GET UP AND GO go to work everyday and she would get on my last nerve if I had to watch her for a half hour show. Do you really think the Food Network needs another Soccer Mommy home cook? She will NOT have "instant credibility" with women who have to work AND take care of their kids! She's just insulting! And she will not have "instant credibility" with women with no kids who go to their jobs everyday either. I mean good for her for not having to work but quit rubbing it in our faces! She seems to have mad cooking skills but so does Jeffery and he is very charming! I'd watch his show for sure.
I would love to have the repipes for episode 7.. especially Melissa's. Why are they not available?
Debbie is less BOOOORING than these two.
Thank you for finally waking up and doing what viewers have seen==dark Debbie==now in this economy we need a Melissa who can cook and has proved herself against all others==she deserves this because she can cook even the renowned pastry chef belived in her now give us Melissa and not Jeffery==again thank you
That's very much my path as well. I was really cool to the idea of Melissa at first. But as the weeks went on I started taking note of the favt that she was very intelligent, and just as importantly, a very good cook. I will definitely give a Melissa show a long, long look. If she can tone it down a couple of notches and keep with the hints, I think FN will get a winner.
As for Jeffrey? Well, he's just okay, there is no 'fire' there. To me just another version of the laid back West Coaster, FN has Chiarelli(?) already, and that's enough of high end wines and cheeses, and innocuous chit chat with innocuous house guests.
I was really cool to the idea of Melissa at first. But as the weeks went on I started taking note of the favt that she was very intelligent, and just as importantly, a very good cook. I will definitely give a Melissa show a long, long look. If she can tone it down a couple of notches and keep with the hints, I think FN will get a winner.
I was really cool to the idea of Melissa at first. But as the weeks went on I started taking note of the fact that she was very intelligent, and just as importantly, a very good cook. I will definitely give a Melissa show a long, long look. If she can tone it down a couple of notches and keep with the hints, I think FN will get a winner.
Thank you, thank you, thank you even though it took you much too long to remove Ms. DL.
Has there ever been a tie for the finalist?The judges seemed to be unable to choose a definite Star last evening. If neither outshines the other what is your criteria for the final choice other than camera ready?
Jeffrey is boring! Go Melissa!
I would have loved to see Debbie win and watch her shows!!!
When is FoodTV going to have show that teaches about Asian or Asian fusion cooking? Don't you think you are leaving out a huge segment of the Asian community? FoodTV just does not get it - your view is too narrow and limited. The entire world is going global and Asian cooking is very popular. Hurry up and get a show that shows you how to cook Asian food!!!!!!
I still think it's a hoot! Thanks for sharing.
lol I loved it!
everything with Anthony Bourdain
I really like Jeffery. Id love to see a show with him. Melissa is ok but doesnt interest me as much.
Word.
I agree with the above poster. She's pushing the mommy track too much. Not everyone has kids, and really nowadays how many women who are working outside will bond with this personality. Yeah she used to work outside the home, but she has the luxury of being a stay at home mom. My vote is for Jeffrey, but he has to step up the energy level and cook a lot more out of his comfort zone.
I thought it would of came down to Debbie & Melissa
I have no interest in watching a show featuring either finalist, so whichever one is selected, it makes no difference to me. They've both had their moments when it appeared as though it was the very first time they ever set foot in a kitchen.
Susie, I think you are very bright and charming and articulate. I love listening to you speak. In fact, I think the judges on this show are amazingly frank and honest. I see little guile and I do believe you speak truthfully about the challenge. You bring up subtleties that show me how deeply you carefully you consider candidates. I am a Melissa fan and I think she can be trained to eliminate some of her annoying little quirky styles. She is very bright and seems determined to be the best she can be. I think she will be a refreshing change. id on't think Jeffrey teaches much, despite the fact that he is clearly a competent cook. I think Melissa will be a star with the right coaching.
I would like to see a cooking show where chefs are challenged to create meals without using specific ingredients. For example, create a complete meal without using grains. Another time eliminate dairy. Chefs are good at cooking from scratch, so have them cook a meal with no processed food…everything has to be fresh, even the seasonings salt crystals and peppercorns allowed. Let's see desserts where honey is the only sweetener allowed.
Although I believe the judges finally got it right by sending Debbie home, I was sad to see her go. I'd like to try some of her recipes, I guess I was hoping that she'd find a way to redeem herself for the giant faux pas that she made along the way.
Of course, without being able to actually taste the food, we often rely on the judges' opinions about them. However, the Red Lobster challenge was a great and easy way to sample the cooking, and I must say that Jeffry's dish was great. Whether he wins or loses in the finals, he has proven that he is a great cook. On top of that, he is easy to watch; he is confident, knowledgeable and excited about food. I hope that Food Network sees it fit to give him a chance to build his audience.
Same thing happened to me. I had 2 paragraphs of comments, maybe it was too long????
I'd watch her over Jeff any day… I don't care if she is a stay at home mom, I would of rather been home taking care of my children my self than having someone else raise them while off to work, staying home and care for the house, kids it a job in it self.. get a life people.. you rock Melissa..
She has that hotdog stand in LA
Don't forget about the live-in nanny, who she tried to take w/her to WA. The nanny would not move. She's a total fake!!
No one said it wasn't a job..believe it or not some people HAVE to take a job away from home and take your kids for someone to watch. They have to get up LEAVE their house and kids every day and GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! I think Melissa is a great cook but I am super tired of her shoving that "I'm so credible" issue down our throats…. I do GO to my job every day so I don't have the luxury of staying at my home and watching the Food Network's newest soccer mommy help me decide what to make for my "man"!! Perhaps You should get a life…away from your home… see what the real world is like!
Really curious as to who else on the Food Network you think is a "soccer mommy?" I'm a fan of both Jeffrey and Melissa, but in her defense, I think she's just trying to show her courage and pump herself up. It's not as though she'll be shouting "I'm a stay at home mom and I have instant credibility with all working moms and stay at home moms" IF she gets her own show. They're both very fun to watch cook!!
I will never watch a show with MELISSA. ALL SHE DID WAS BLAME THE OTHERS FOR EVERYTHING. Send her home.
HOW DID BOBBY FLAY EVER GET HIS OWN SHOW??? AND HOW CAN HE BE A JUDGE???? HE SOUNDS LIKE A FAG.
MY FAMILY ALSO IS SICK OF RACHEL RAY. ALL HER RECIPES HAVE NOT TURNED OUT. IT'S LIKE SHE JUST THROWS ANYTHING TOGETHER TO HAVE A SHOW. MY FAMILY AND FRIENDS DO NOT WATCH HER ANYMORE. WE CALL HER DUMMY.
Yes, they ARE boring. Is Melissa all you can find to compete???
Sick of MELISSA. ALL SHE DOES IS BRAG ABOUT HERSELF AND RUN DOWN THE OTHERS. SHE NEEDS TO GO BACK TO TEXAS AND STAY.
Do think the three remaining finalists were significantly better than the the others who were eliminated. But of the remaining three, I thought that Debbie and Melissa equally could have been eliminated. And, I do expect that Melissa will go out in the next round. She is clearly competent but just not that interesting and not that steady under stress.
I am soooooo glad you finally got rid of Debbie but why it took you so long is beyond me. I think Jeffrey should be the winner, Melissa is to risky because she starts talking a mile a minute. I don't think I could watch her very long. Check out the old Emeril shows and see how he was in the beginning (before Emeril Live) and see how far he has come. I think Jeffrey can do the same if given the chance.
AMEN AMEN AMEN
GO MELISSA!!!
Hi Susie,
I really enjoy visiting your blogs as well as Bob's. I was wondering if after the finale this next Sun, will these blogs be shut down? I'm hoping they will at least remain open for a short while so we can discuss the outcome of the show. We have come too far just to have it all stop now.
Enter text right here!
I would enjoy more shows like an updated version of "Follow that Food" (I think it's on "Style" channel). Getting very TIRED of Rachel Ray, Giada, Guy Fieri, etc. I think an instructional Asian cuisine show would be good, or more of Daisy Martinez. It might be nice to have a baking show, especially for those viewers who are intimidated by baking breads, danish pastries, etc.
Enter text right here!DON'T YOU THINK THAT MELISSA IS HYPER? AND WHAT IS GOING TO DO WITH HER FOUR CHILDREN IF SHE HAS TO TAPE IN NY. SORRY I LOVE JEFFREY'S RECIPIES
I would watch both Jeffrey and Melissa. I think they should both get their own show. Jeffrey has the type of food I would love to try however, for my day to day family meals, and cooking on a budget, I would love to get some ideas from Melissa. When Melissa has her 'harried housewife' moments, although it is not pleasant to watch on a regular basis, we all feel that way in the kitchen at times!
Happened to me too, a couple of weeks ago. I had the audacity to mention that they gave Aaron McCargo a chance (I never watch him now as the first couple of episodes were enough); that they got rid of JAG for dishonesty, that Adam Gertler's show idea was given to some woman. Well, if Jeffrey doesn't get this season, I'm done with TNFNS.
Jeffrey & Melissa BOTH should have a show………..(just like Adam and now what's her name).,,………. and just for putting up with Debbie, et.al. what a full of herself loser………….and her Judge that EVEN tells other judges NOT to think CAPERS were important to leave out!!!!
Our favorite cooking shows are Bravo's Top Chef and The Next Food Network Star. I agree with a comment below that it would be interesting to see the chefs try to cook something without grain or dairy. My entire family has to be cow-dairy free (but can use sheep or goat) and would be nice to see what chefs could come up with and share their recipes. Also, we love anything Bobby Flay does and watch all of his shows. Keep Melissa - as a stay at home mom and an owner of two businesses I would watch her and have been impressed with the dept of her knowledge of different areas - Spain/France etc.
I have used many of Ina's recipes and most of them are great. However, I never use the same amount of salt that she does. But some of her chicken dishes, salmon, pot roast, were excellent. I recently made her granola, it too is delicious.
Bobby Flay has been on FN for many, many years with various formats. He is an accomplished chef, especially his grilling techniques. I've eaten in one of his NYC restaurants, wow, pricey, but worth the splurge.
I am confused about Melissa. One day she said her mom was military and single mom. They lived very poor part of Arizona. Another day she said they had nunnery. Very poor part of town and Nunnery? Another show she said she has lived in Paris .When she presented her meal and she dropped bomb. Her mom got suicide! I don't know she was telling truth or what? She never mentioned her husband, but she has four small children. Who is taking care of her kids now? Don’t tell us I am working mom routine.
I like him too
I agree with you about the over exposure -especially Rachael Ray and Giada. Also, like to see Guy in a different kind of show.3D is same old same old after the first season. Woul also like to see some Asian programins (sans Debbie).
I love Top Chef and anything Bobby Flay. Would like to see Mike Symone in something and what happened to Mario, Emeril and Morimoto?
Jeffery has tried to take everyone out by accusing them of one thing or another. At least Melissa would be honest. Give her a show about how to shop for groceries, stocking your pantry, etc.each week with just one or two simple recipes to prepare. She is a home cook and prepares dinner every day for a family. I think we need to hear more of that, expecially in today's economic situation. Simple dishes that are not too expensive. I know I would. She has a rather quiet voice and explains herself well. I do not wast Big Daddy and I will not watch Jeffery is he get a show. More and more you are losing me. I
Jeffery has tried to take everyone out by accusing them of one thing or another. At least Melissa would be honest. Give her a show about how to shop for groceries, stocking your pantry, etc.each week with just one or two simple recipes to prepare. She is a home cook and prepares dinner every day for a family. I think we need to hear more of that, expecially in today's economic situation. Simple dishes that are not too expensive. I know I would. She has a rather quiet voice and explains herself well. I do not waste time on Big Daddy and I will not watch Jeffery if he get a show. More and more you are losing me.
I think that, in the future, FN should change the format of TNFNS. As this season's shows emerged there was great blandness exposed. Perhaps, some of the contestents that were sent home at the beginning of the season were sent home too soon, before their true strenghths and weaknesses could have been ferreted out. Maybe all contestents should be given the first three programs as a proving ground–and then, thereafter, let the eliminations begin.
PBS has a variety of cooking shows starring different ethnic backgrounds. Were at it years before Food Network.
Jeffrey should be the winner. He has been himself through-out the entire process and never did the crying or frantic confusion of Melissa. Melissa is a phony with her stay-at-home mommy crediability. How do we know she cooks every night! She was in the business world so her home-body stuff is just recent and she has no real past history tips that would merit be called "cooking knowlege". She is a recent mom, recent (possibly) stay-at-home mom and how could anyone who really enjoys cooking become so bouncing off the wall when posed with a cooking problem…real cooks find cooking their element and settle down in the kitchen not become a taz-type devil when food comes at them "too fast & furious"…again Melissa is a phony with her bleeding heart "my mother being a single mom" story. Life is life, Jeffrey may be "vanilla" as you call him but maybe everyday people are and it would be good to come home a straight-forward cook and none of the Melissa hipe.
I for one think that it's time to learn to love people just the way they are. I LIE! I am not proud of it, but i hope the world doesn't crucify me because I do. And if anyone of you say you don't lie, then you are liers!!! Point is, all three of the finalists are capable of doing a show, but only the people who are NOT self righteous can watch them all.
I hope Melissa wins. I would definitely watch her. She seems to be a great cook and has a lot of practical knowledge to share. Jeffrey would put me to sleep. He may be a good cook, but his personality puts me to sleep. However,I would watch him as a guest on Melissa's show.
Thanks for the input-I especially like the baking show-I am one of the intimidated non-bakers myself.
thanks!
I like Gordon Ramsey-the chef you love to hate (and never work for…) Love to see him on an episode of Iron Chef. Thanks for your suggestions.
You see, I think Jeffrey is the most boring. Yes, he's very steady under pressure, but he's just not very animated. And I see no change in him from episode one. I will say I predict he'll be the ultimate winner. Melissa is very animated and each week we learn more about her and she learns more about the job.
Over the years, there have been excellent cooking shows on many networks, but I think what you are looking for here, is a way to take the pulse on what would be the next "hit" for TFN. Reality shows are getting old in my book, love Gordon Ramsey but the rage is getting old, HUMOR, on the other hand, never goes out if style. I agree that I would like to see Michael Symon in a different setting, he and Mario have such a wonderful sense of humor, maybe a "round table" humorous setting where cooking solutions, styles, tips and more are discussed or demo'd? Of course, I am just one person, but I do have to agree that Giada is boring!, Rachael's voice grates on my nerves and I change channels on both of them immediately. Guy is great, and I think he keeps things fresh. The Neelys seem repetitive and the whole, "stay at home mom" thing, I don't get it, a working mom has time constraints, etc, being home all day is more challenging because why?????
As a feminist from the 70's, a wife, mother, and an educator, I am going to make a comment that I thought I would never make. While Melissa is nice and knows how to cook, I think there are enough shows with a female home cook (Ina, RR, R Miller, etc.), so why do you think I need another?
Secondly, she has 4 kids under 4. Who has been cooking for them for the last month, at the very least? I am not saying she should not go for it, but as Barbara Walters once said, "We can have it all, but just not all at the same time." It is an illusion to think otherwise, in my opinion. Think Amy Finley. Melissa is in an enviable position that most women are not in: she has lots of options. Fine. To imply that she is a stay at home mom, making delicious meals for her family seems a bit questionable at this point. She is not doing it all.
Susie, aren't you just a bit afraid that you are going to hire another Amy F.? 4 kids under 4-anything can happen to tip over that apple cart! Unless she has the cooking show in her home, there will be sacrifices.
I love the show and watch as much as possible. I like both of the last two but I would like to see Melissa be the winner. I think she would be a good host, and make cooking fun. I love to cook and after watching the network I try all kinds of new foods.
I am getting tired of the same old, same old shows. Rereun after rerun. I would like some fresh faces. Enough of Paula and Giada and Rachel for a while (I love them tho). Guy is the best. Love Ina too. Don't care much for the Deen boys
Like both finalists would watch either one. Don't watch as much as I used to. I was an addict. Shows are just getting boring
I agree!!!!!!!!!! Jeffrey is the full package and I know I would watch him. The 'susie' you picked from San Diego was awful and I never watched her at all—-no show, right. I would have watched Rory. I thought she was great. Melissa over smiles giving a false pretence. Sorry!!!!!!!!
She is an awesome cook. A little too upscale for me tho. I don't think we need to comment on her weight-its a cooking show
I soooo agree. I also think she tries to use what happened in her past to gain sympathy points. Not trying to be mean here, but how exactly did her mom's suicide fit in? Also she said she had a nanny growing up, but that they had to eat skirt steak alot because they were poor? How are you poor AND have a nanny? I love Jeffrey and would watch him all the time. And, this is off the point, but Giada is boring and spends too much time in front of the mirror
WHEN has Jeffery ever accused anyone of anything? I don't recall him acting any less than an honest, integrous gentleman. The ONLY possible exception would be after the Miami party and he included himself in the poor results of that fiasco.
Jenn
This is getting rediculous. Jeffrey has always has always been a gentleman. I can't remember him accusing anyone of anything even when he probably should have.
Ina got her show because of her best selling cookbooks & her very successful food shop. Her recipes are very dependable & turn out great. The photography is especially good — it really focuses on the food, less on Ina during preparation. She balances the food with details on entertaining in many different scenarios, but without "tablescapes" or elaborate decorations.
I don't inderstand the need for such vitrole! If you don't like a particular host, don't watch. I love Ina. I've tried many of her recipes and find them to be delicious. I would like to better understand the process timewarner used to collect the data warranting such strong statements? Has she/he actually tasted something Ina cooked or perhaps, did he/she lack success when he/she tried an Ina recipe.
By the way, timewarner, have you heard of the Barefoot Contessa? Look in your gourmet store.
Relax and peace be with you. c
Melissa age 1-3 had a Spanish-speaking nanny (babysitter) while her then single mom attended college. Later her mom joined the Navy, so there wasn't much money. Melissa's mom died when Melissa was 20, so she then supported herself through college by being a personal chef for a family. She's worked on cruise ships & had an executive career. She worked for Disney in Paris, France, & met her husband there. Now she's back in the USA with 4 daughters under 5, 2 of them twins. She's also 40 — plenty of time to do all that.
These comments are really therapy for the fans. The situation with Debbie revealed how little our voice is considered. Clearly, Debbie should have been removed much earlier. It irks me to think others may have succeeded had she been removed. We are left with the "survivors"……not necessary the best.
The real process should be to vote like Dancing with the Stars. There could be a system where the judges have 50% of the votes and the viewers have the other 50%. Then, the NFNS contestants would be picked in part by those who would watch them while still giving those investing in the NFNS some control.
I was wondering the same thing and I'd like to get the facts about all these conflicting stories
I will never watch a show that Melissa hosts. She blamed the others for their mistakes. She is not bright. She never mentions any husband. Maybe she doesnt have one with her attitude.
I like Melissa alot! I would definately watch her a show. I'm a busy mom too and would love great recipes that I can get on the table fast. Someone has to remember that we dont work in five star restaurants and dont always have access to high end ingredients.
Must you SHOUT EveryTHING?
I agree with you Teresa and I disagree with the judges who think Debbie has the "cooking chops" to make it. She was very inconsistent with her dishes. The only ones that I considered worth much of anything were the appetizers she made in Miami, however, in order to make them so good, she again had that "every man for himself" attitude that caused her to put her head down and work only on her two dishes. She definitely made herself a distinct advantage, while letting the kitchen she was supposed to be in charge of go down the tubes. There were other dishes that she said were southern or Korean that were definitely not either. We were just supposed to buy whatever she wanted to sell us. So why did the judges?
I would love to see an Asian cooking show as well. I've been a student of Chinese cooking for about thirty years and would love to see a full panorama of Asian cooking; not just Chinese or Korean, but Japanese and Philippino, too Having a chef with questionable cooking skills and integrity is not something the FN needs to settle for in order to have such a show.
How about the pot stickers or the meat loaf sauce? Those were really wonderful contributions- almost as good as the angel food cake and the pudding.
MEOW…….
I like you, meow.
I would never buy her books. I don't like the way (when she speaks) she slurps. And yes I have tried her recipes and I also dont like how she says to """use good vanilla or """use good oil. What does she think we use. Also, why does she cook for all those single men.
Felina, I agree with your first sentence, but I do have a question. Do you have any idea why you lie? It's usually not necessary and the truth will always come out eventually anyway. I've known and met alot of people who just enjoy lying to see what they can get away with. They more often than not find out the answer is, "not much." As for your rule that self righteous people "cannot watch them all," that's very seldom got anything to do with what people do or don't watch. It's about entertainment, the person at center stage and on FN, the cooking education that many are seeking. Most of us regular folks don't have time to go to culinary school, so we learn from the chefs on FN. If the teacher turns us off, we drop the class, just like in college. A lack of integrity is often a turnoff, not because the person is "self righteous, " but because they just don't like the feeling of being lied to.
I'm so glad you are down to my favorite two. I actually like Jeffrey more, he seems to be very interesting. I want to know more about him. I also believe he will bring food that is not so mainstream. I've seen the basics over and over and am ready to move on to more challenging and unfamiliar foods. Your current line-up is kind of stale for me, as a long-time viewer. However, two new favorites of mine are Anne Burrell and Sunny Andersen. They bring a wonderful new freshness in food and technique. Although I do like Melissa a lot, but find myself insulted by her tag as a stay at home mom, like it's terribly difficult. Of course it is, (I've done both) but, it is so very heart-wrenching to HAVE to leave your children with someone else and HAVE to go to work AND manage a home and family. Now that's a real challenge. Wouldn't we all like to stay at home and watch our kids first events, walking, talking, etc. When she says this, the connection and credibility is not being made, it makes her appear as a spoiled wife who is able to do as she pleases, work or not. So I hope she feels blessed and does well, but my hope is ultimately in Jeffrey!
Debbie was perfectly happy to take the assignment of head chef in the miami kitchen. In fact she jumped at it, saying that she caters "some of the hottest parties in Hollywood." If you see her name and address in the current Phoenix phone directory, how are you supposed to believe THAT in the first place? More Debbie exaggerating her own skills and accomplishments. When it comes time to deliver, she didn't! Even Bobby Flay said it was the chef's responsiblity if the kitchen blew up. She wanted it, she got it, she blew it.
Deborah, agree with everything you say. My take on Debbie is that she comes off like a very phony saleswoman who is trying like heck to sell a product she knows is inferior, but tries to cover that with a lot of phony ingratiating, smiling and just assuming that if she says it runs like a top, we should darn well believe her. She's like a cat who sticks his head under the bed thinking that because he can't see you, he is well hidden. In realtiy, his whole bottom half is exposed!
Speaking of Anne B., She comes off as a lot of fun on her show, but on judging panels she always looks extremely constipated and like she's looking for a contestant chef to blame it on.
Debbie was so unpoised that she forgot that Bobby gave her the capers and then got caught in her own lie-web. hee hee…
They make money on them in cookbooks or their magazine. They're not going to give them to us for free.
Shelburne, on MASH, they buried the Kimchee in the ground, remember? When Hawkeye dug it up, it almost knocked him on his can!
You are forgetting the rest of the chefs on FN say exactly what she said. When she speaks, it is very calm and you can understand it. All of her recipes are great and easy to make. Who cares who she cooks for. Quit being jealous about it.
I don't know who you think you are but if you think that you can cook better than Ina than why don't you have your own show? You made a nasty comment about her size. How dare you. Ina is sweet and has many people who love her for that. As far as how shecan cook……. I have made many, many of her recipes and they are all wonderful. I own all of her books. Why don't you get a life other than to be nasty. Does it make you feel good to be nasty especially to those that don't deserve it? Oh and by the way, this blog is about TNFNS………. Idiot!!!!!!
"I" did not say Debbie was poised, I said Susie said that she was poised. I will also say that Debbie did not use the capers on purpose and lied several times to try and make excuses for herself. And based upon her exit interview she is also delusional.
Neko,
I think you are confused about a lot of things? A nunnery is a convent of nuns! Did you mean nanny? When Melissa was young she probably had a spanish speaking babysitter and when she was speaking about it, used the more current term of nanny. Yes, she lived in Paris, FOR HER JOB! I can tell you, if my bossed walked in and told me I was being transferred to the Paris office, I'd be out the door, packing my bags! And suicide is NOT something you get like a cold. Her mother committed suicide. Why should she tell us about her husband? Is that any of your business? The children's father can take care of them while she is taping.
I think Jeffry did a wonderful job…I'm a home cook from a french & italian household for the past 50 years..I find his dishes to hard & running around to follow…..Please,Please give us Melissa's the home cook that doesn't use 3 pounds of butter 25 eggs,& seasonings that don't cost a fortune!! I love Ina but I cannot drive down the road to a farm stand & get a fresh duck,berries,wine & whatever!!! GO MELISSA
Give Jeffrey and Melissa their own shows.
I agree. I had trouble with Debbie from the first episode when she was in charge of shopping for her group but put back several key ingredients for the others. She seems to lack integrity. I would not want to be on her team.
I so agree with you. When I watch an FN show, I want to enjoy the person I'm watching. I disliked Debbie's personality from the first episode. I'm amazed that she made it as far as she did. With her continuing displays of deception, dishonesty, and ego, I cringed each time she was on.
Yes, I have watched all episodes this year and have found it quite interesting. I amdelighted with the last two standing. My favorite? Melissa! Why? Yes she is a Mom and a home cook but how many millions are out here in TV land are in the same category. I would have been intimidated meeting all of the chefs as she has been. I, too, am not a chef, only a grandma that has worked all my life and is now interested in cooking and baking. Jeffrey is fine but I wish he would either style his hair or wash it more often. Pretty greasy to ME! ANYWAY, I HOPE THAT MELISSA WINS! I THINK SHE WILL BE THE GEM OF THE NETWORK. Surely will be watching Sunday night.
Do Melissa and Jeffery know ahead of the sunday night show who is going to win?
What surprises me most about the "The Next Food Network Star" is the vetting process. It's really hard to believe these contestants were the best of the best of all the applications you received. All the crying and back-biting — it's like high school. These people do not have the star quality of Bobby Flay or Paula Deen, not even close. Pick stronger contentants and you'll have a better show.
Sadly, I have seen the writing on the wall the past few carefully edited episodes: Melissa is the winner. We saw her go from modest to egomaniac in record time. Her stories don't jibe and she is extremely annoying. I will NOT watch her show (as I do not watch the over-the-top Guy Fee- EDDIE. Maybe FN is trying to appeal to a younger crowd and wider variety of viewers, but they are losing me. Gordon Elliott should have kept himself on with "Door Knock Dinners!" One of my favorites, now long gone…..
Glad Debbie has FINALLY BEEN ELIMINATED!!! She did not have the honesty and just said what she thought the judges wanted to hear and I would not want to watch her show. It was not fair Jamieka and others were eliminated in the previous weeks at her expense. Jameika obviously has a beautiful prescence, likable personality and a distinct culinary point of view that is real and not forced. I hope the FN rethinks and brings Jameika back with her own show.
I agree with Troy about the challenge and basically agree with the remaining two, even though I would prefer to watch Melissa, she has more appeal to me and my friends…..we all work and would love to see how to make meals that she does. Her last challenge my husband and I would like all of her recipes over the others….can't wait to try hers…
Neko, you should read her bio and alot of your questions would be answered.
Neko, you should read her bio and alot of your questions would be answered.
I totally agree! That is why I am hoping Melissa wins! She doesn't Make food that is so hot people can't eat it. Even Paula Dean is now leanining toward making super spicy foods. Melissa cooks for the normal family with kids and grand kids. We need a show with a chef who does that!
If they both can't win then it needs to be Melissa who does! Jeffery is great, however he tends to cook very spicy foods. A lot of people cant eat that kind of spice and young kids dont and won't eat it!
From the moment I saw Jeff in the very first episode, I thought he would win.
He has a presence that is comfortable, relaxed, kind of quirk and a great sense of humor. He thinks fast on his feet.
Watching Melissa would frankly up set me. It's not just the hyper-bubbly thing, but I sense something more visceral about her.
I agree with Bobby Flay when he asked her, "Where did all this fire come from?" and You're scaring me today."
She gets wound up and she is scary!
Can't wait for the finale tonight. I agree that the last two standing are the best choices. I like both of them very much but I do love Melissa's recipes and she certainly does "light up the room". I love all of FN's chefs and look forward to the newest star. I told my family and friends that if I ever end up in a Nursing Home unable to speak, to please write Food Network on my forhead and make sure that I have my own personal cable TV at bedside turned on FN at all times. Horrible thought but at least it would be tolerable. Thanks, Sue Nicklaus
I never believed for one moment Melissa would be the next food network star. Gimmick! Jeffrey has the training and the appeal he needs in order to be on television.
This was the first v-blog I've seen of Susie's and I was floored by her one-word answers and her flip/glib attitude! Made me regret being such a fan of the show. I would never have guessed she could be that way - if they didn't like "attitude" in Jamika, what is this we see in SUSIE?
You hit the nail on the head, K. Waite. What a disappointment.
Really? You HATE blondes?! What an asinine generalization coming from one so seemingly well-spoken.
Oh well, you obviously have had some past experiences that color your view. Nice to see that you are open-minded enough to allow someone the possibility of changing that view!
Who knows . . . maybe she dyes it!
food network made another error in picking a finalist.
Melissa is soo empty! I know I will not be watching her show.
She has nothing to offer . I hope they will give Jeffery a show,he is interesting and a likeable guy you want to know.
Hello, Jeffrey should have won!!! Melissa is sweet, but not all of us have a busy life style. My six children are adults. Food Network
already has great shows. I wanted to watch and learn a new world
ingredient every show, that got me excited. I have always believed that all people of the world are alike when it comes to foods. Same
but different….biscuits to some,fry bread to others. Darn I wanted to watch Jeffrey's show!!! Sharon Kerr, Fayetteville, Arkansas
I am so happy Melissa won, her dishes really seemed to impress the judges (where is that cookie recipe of hers?), and it seems like you could make them for your family or any guests. Jeffrey was great too, but I would most likely only use his recipes for certain people/ special occasions, who has time to go search for the secret ingredient? they are both great and likable but I think Melissa will really inspire more people to expand their everyday cooking recipes and gain more confidence in the kitchen.
What a huge mistake choosing Mellisa as next food network star,her pilot was not even good, comparing to jeffrey , the guy was very enjoyable to watch, and learn a lot from , to be hounest i get very anoyed watching Mellisa, and her for step recepie for her piolet was very stupid. I was looking forward to watch Jeffrey show , so i am very very disapointed now !!
Melissa is good for harried women trying to cook after a day at work or chasing around a bunch of kids. It's Melissa to the rescue. But, Jeffrey brought excitement to the kitchen. What would he do next? Where has he travelled to and what has he eaten while there. His pilot was like the intelligent, thinking person's version of Bizarre FOODS WITH andrew Zimmern. I hope FN finds a show for Jeffrey. His POV is fresh while Melissa's has been done again and again…Sonny Anderson, 5 ingredient meals, the cooking healthy woman with short hair, the skinny woman who makes one thing and uses it in 4 meals. They are all the same! And they are all female. I want to see Jeffrey and learn from him. BAD CHOICE, GUYS!! For SHAME.
Once again the network had an agenda…Jeffrey has a distinct point of view with various spices and a mid eastern flt which is sorely missing on the Network. melissa's chicken was sooo boring..it must be made in millions of kitchens daily. It's the l;ook…cute..blonde..etc. get over it and try to be more diversified in your offerings. Please find a spot for Jeffrey..preferebly at 4pm.
I find Melissa very hard to watch. She talks too fast and smiles too much. I think she probably is a great cook but she does not have star quality. I will watch her show to see if she improves, if not I'll skip her show. She actually has a very annoying personality and thinks she's better then she really is. She comes across as phony.
Jeffery is more natural in front of the camera and would have been my choice as the winner. He's much easier to watch and seems to be genuine.
Didereaux,
Why would you prejudge someone based on their hair color? Seems odd to me. Just wondering.
Are they Korean hot dogs??
Jeffery did his job in the Miami party, Debbie was the one that worked on her dishes and her dishes only. She was supposed to be running the kitchen. She knew that ahead of time. I agree with you 100%, Jeffery has always been honest and a gentleman. I'm just sad that Melissa & Jeffery couldn't do a show together although Melissa was my choice due to not being able to eat spicy foods.
The luxury of being a stay at home Mom??? Have you ever tried it?? I am a stay at home Mom and the demands that are put on me at home vs. working outside of the home, please. A stay at home Mom's job NEVER ends and she does not get bonuses or pay rasises or does she get to go to Holiday parties. Each positon has it advantages and disadvantages.
Aren't you referring to Debbie??? Melissia was accountable and took the suggestions from the judges and applied them. Thank goodness Debbie was sent home!!!
As long as Debbie isn't the host!!!!!
Would it be only because you would be waiting for the next lie to come out of her mouth???
And what would that be??? Is there enough lying and back-stabbing going on in this world to begin with and then to put Debbie out there as a FN "STAR??"
I couldn't agree more.
My favorite no-cook option is always a salad, and one of my favorite new shows on Food Network is Claire Robinson’s 5 Ingredient Fix. Luckily, Claire actually did a No-Cook Dinner episode of her show recently, so I put together Claire’s Antipasti Chopped Salad for a quick, light dinner. It was fantastic!