Chef Guarnaschelli’s Butter!

by in View All Posts, December 2nd, 2008

Last year, Babbo. This year, Butter. Am I speaking gibberish? Not quite. Each year, my honey, Hagan, and I forgo anniversary presents in exchange for an extra luscious celebration dinner. Last year, for our three year anniversary, we indulged ourselves at Mario Batali’s restaurant, Babbo, off of Washington Square Park. Although that experience warrants a post dedicated to itself, I’ll skip right to the current year and give you the dish about Alex Guarnaschelli’s restaurant, Butter!


Alex describes food the way most discuss art. Before Chef Guarnaschelli snagged her own Food Network show, The Cooking Loft, I loved hearing her skillfully shaped notes as a judge on Iron Chef America. (And I definitely look forward to hearing her commentary on FN’s new show, Chopped, this January!) So it was a total no brainer what restaurant got my vote for our special dinner.

At the New York Wine & Food Festival, I ran into Alex where my director then spilled I was thinking about Butter for my anniversary dinner. Without missing a beat, she said, “How dare you not email me. Stop being ridiculous. Email me and let me book your reservation.” I waited a week to hide a bit of my anxiousness. But when I finally did email her, Alex quickly shot back, sending well wishes and confirming the dinner reservation she made personally for us.


Alas, I did not plan for the mood lighting (aka too dark to take pictures without flash), so apologies for the “mood lit” camera phone photos!

We feasted on seared Maine sea scallops, cavatappi pasta with yellow tomato sauce and spicy lamb sausage, chanterelle ravioli, Hudson Valley duck breast, a lovely trout dish (I forget the pretty name), and a dark chocolate cake with pumpkin ice cream for dessert…

The top bite of the night? Hagan swore that the scallops were the best he’s ever had, but for me…and this may sound a bit ridiculous…but my favorite component in the whole meal was the simple, yellow tomato sauce. Sounds boring, right? Well I’ve heard before that you can judge a good chef by their soup, but there must be some truth to judging a chef by their tomato sauce. Now I’m not sure if this is the same recipe that Chef Guarnaschelli uses at Butter (I’ll try to do some investigating), but I did find this Yellow Tomato Sauce recipe of hers from The Cooking Loft — has anyone tried it?

With only 361 days to go to my next anniversary, I thought I might start taking a poll of where to go to for next year’s celeberation. Have you tried any of Food Network’s chefs’ restaurants? Paula Deen’s Lady and Sons? Bobby Flay’s Mesa Grill or newly opened Burger Palace? Guy Fieri’s Johnny Garlics or Tex Wasabi’s? Neelys Barbecue? Morimoto’s Morimoto? Michael Symon’s Lola or Lolita?

Tell me about your visit!

Rachael Knudsen
Associate Producer, The FN Dish

More posts from .

Similar Posts

Made-Over Game-Day Recipes to Lighten Up Your Party

Make better-for-you versions of game-day classics....

Comments (9)

  1. Robin Koury says:


    You are a girl after my own heart! Every year my husband and I say goodbye to candy, flowers, and gifts but we say hello to a magnificent dinner together. Its been our tradition for the past 8 years and I couldn’t imagine spending our anniversary any other way. This year we are off to Mesa Grill and I’m on a full fledged countdown! I’m thrilled to hear your dinner at Butter was fabulous…How exciting to have Alex Guarnaschelli herself make your reservations, I probably would have passed out if it were me! Even though the photo of Butter is dark it almost sets a romantic mood for the evening and the tree is incredibly festive! I’d be lying if I didn’t say I’m jealous…With only 361 days to go where will you spend your 4th anniversary…Time to get serious and don’t forget to “dish”!

  2. Lana says:

    No celebrity chefs have restaurants near where I live. But I did travel to CA to visit family for thanksgiving. We went to Johnny Garlic’s for lunch and had a very nice meal, super friendly service. I had a french dip sandwich (nothing stellar, but it was tasty enough). The winner at the table was the Lava Shrimp Saute. They declined giving me the recipe, but I think I might give it a whirl on my own, and see if I can’t develop something close to it. :-)

  3. Andrea says:

    I’ve eaten at Mesa Grill and at the Lady and Sons. Both were delicious. Bobby’s restaurant is what I expected, great quality, imaginative ingredients, and delicious! Paula’s was also as I expected, yummy and filling! I could definitely tell I was eating her recipes with how quickly I was full! I would suggest both.

  4. Magnificent goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you are just too fantastic. I actually like what you've acquired here, really like what you're stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep it wise. I cant wait to read much more from you. This is actually a tremendous site.

  5. gadget zine says:

    i found Chef Guarnaschelli’s Butter! | The FN Dish – Food Network Blog Really good visual appeal on this website , I'd rate it 10 10.

  6. Aw my spouse and i thought i thought this was quite a fantastic post On thought Groundbreaking, i was put on hand writing in this manner moreover – spending some time and exact effort carryout a

  7. It may just be too complicated and intensely broad in my circumstances. I am looking forward for your other article, and I would really prefer to get it! Really this publication is certainly spreading her wings easily, searching as it…

  8. Today, while I was at work, my sister stole my iPad and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is entirely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  9. Super Bowl says:

    In the real-world, the Super Bowl is concerning lots of things. Nfl football is simply one.
    Primarily, the Super Bowl is focused on the media.
    That’s not a slam on nfl football. Pro football has undoubtedly come to be our most desired countrywide sport, for several different motives. Certainly no other game, in no way Supermodel Jell-O Wrestling, could possibly bring just about anywhere in close proximity to the 108.5 million people that saw last February’s Super Bowl.
    Will there be another situation in tv history, or even human beings history as an example, exactly where hundreds of thousands of people were so wanting to listen to sales pitches?
    It’s possibly true, evidently, that the majority of of people aren’t gonna take note of our favorite advertisings and rush off to purchase the product.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>